Added: 5 years ago
From: hanamayflower
Views: 4,677,994
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,525)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • No words can describe how wonderrful this performance is!!! That is all...

  • I can't get enough of her voice, it's just so...i don't know...confident... ^_^

  • After watching this performance is when I realized she was going to be the first American Idol <3

    And she's still going strong :)

  • one word-shivers

  • ima straight dude, and i love her stuff!

  • celine huber is much better^^

  • I want to cry every time I hear this song, I am so doing a cover. :D

    Also, she is SO stunning, I am officially jealous of everything about her.

  • One of my FAVORITE Kelly songs. Such a strong voice.

  • Celine von Unser Star für Baku, ist mal übertrieben gut !! Hoffentlich gewinnt die ! x33

  • Jaa gell, die war sau guut *-* ♥

  • Celine von Unser Star für Baku schickt mich! <3

  • @Quehllllll Leider ist die deutlich schlechter.

  • celina from unser star für baku is the best!

  • @CrazykriZy bring me here 2 xD

  • @CrazykriZy du meinst wohl CÉLINE ;)

  • wow i think this is amazing thank you for posting

  • she makes every song special...

  • this is so beautiful. (not a beautiful disaster, a beautiful melody). love this song.

  • I love this song. I love that album. I love her! :)))))

  • I knew this song before that euch covered it on the X Factor. Frankly, Kelly sings all her songs that are covered 10000000000000 times better...

  • the fuck? this isn't 311...gay

  • i klicked at kelly clarkson youtube mix and this (nr. 12) was the first one not banned by the GEMA ...

  • Kelly sang this on the finale of season 2 or 3. It was on the "Thankful" CD. This acoustic version was much better! Kelly was made for acoustic versions. Her voice is awesome!! LOVE her!!

  • Kitty's version doesn't even come close to this. Wow great job, Kelly.

  • heard it the first time for a couple of days ago - do you know the feeling when a song could be the song the describes your whole life... That was so haunting and heartbreaking!

    thumbs up, love this song!

  • Suits my mood so much right now :')

  • Thank god for a beautiful voice. Think that K Clarkson has an amazing voice

  • who is the original singer?

  • @evariu Kelly Clarkson. It was released on her debut album, Thankful back in 2003.

  • her hair is do pretty in this! <3

  • Ive always been a Kelly Clarkson fan. Kitty will never be as good as her. BUT I think Kitty has a good voice-perhaps the only powerhouse vocalist that was in the compitition this year. Remember this world would be very boring without a few people being nuts. I mean DAMN IT she had a good voice. why do people fell so threatend by something a bit different.

  • this "kitty" from x factor may have brought you here... but she's definitely not better than Kelly

  • Has anyone noticed that all of Kelly's videos are getting a lot more of views?

  • @37JoeKing That's a pretty good thing ^^ I am glad she has the recognition she deserves, she is so talented :)

  • @chance793 Fuck yeah! Kelly for the win *-* hahaha. You're right! 

  • I've always liked Kitty from X-factor but this version is WAY better than the one she did

  • omg 208 dislikes, thats not cool, THEY R BLIND As FUCK, KELLY IS AMAZING

  • Wow, she looks just like Bethany Joy Galeotti here !

    I love Kelly, I would kill to go to one of her shows <3

  • @chance793 omg she does! and that's so weird because i always say they look alike!

  • uh, kelly. youre amazing. just saying.

  • 206 people are disasters and they aren't beautiful.

  • NIGGERS.

  • ali

  • :')

  • Kelly is boss.

    Kitty... average.

  • kitty and kelly should do a duet :) it'd be interesting and hopefully good

  • I honestly prefer this version...but hey!! i Looove kitty! i think she's awesome!!

  • amazing =)

  • this is such a great performance!!..One of my Kelly favorites..

  • Kitty Brucknell did an amazing version of it :)

  • Kitty Brucknell did this far better wwwhhhhaooooo 

  • @TheKeithfarren18 : r u deaf or stupid?

  • @hideaway78 kitty is far better and bigger voice... and ps i like kelly although kittys class

  • @TheKeithfarren18 : Kelly put her heart and soul into this song; really more emotion than Kittys.

  • I dont see why everyone is talking about the x factor on a video of kelly clarkson. If you wanna go talk about kitty go watch HER performance of this song... Kelly doesnt get enough credit for how good she is as it is. 

  • That's really great, but give Kitty a break; she did a great job of it too and made it hers.

    If Kelly's version is better, one of the reasons is she is allowed to sing the whole song, something X-Factor has a real problem with.

  • kelly clarkson sang this amazingly. kitty needs 2 stay singing gaga and madonna she could never sing like this!

  • Kitty sang it beautifull too

  • so moving.

  • my heart...

  • SO FREAKING HEART TOUCHING!

  • I thought the lassie Kitty sung this song beautifully and i also like Kelly Clarkson as well.

  • Never heard this untill Kitty sang it, i may just download it, it's a lovely song.

  • Hugely dissapointed with this..Kitty from X Factor had much more emotion in her performance

  • Kitty sang it well......leave her alone

  • THIS is how you sing Beautiful Disaster....Kitty...You are shameful

  • @melisawr omg completley agree! she was absolute karaoke compared to this!

  • This is my shit :)

  • @cyntoriav Welcome to the club :)

  • She's HOT in here... keke

  • The best live performance ever!!!! not many people people cna sing like this live!!!!!!!!! Go Kelly <3 thumbs up if u agree

  • check out my coverrr..♥ this song

  • Kelly has got it all going on. Mad talent. I love her so much. I just recently started to listen to all of her music. I had heard the ones on the radio, but hearing her other music is so incredible. She is very creative, talented, dark, yet full of light, versatile, and I absolutely adore when she sings with Reba Mcentire. She holds her own and sings like she's been in the business FOREVER. She is just as good, if not better, than Reba(sorry Reba-I love you both).

  • Kitty Brucknell X factor brought me here and She did amazing!!

  • GODDAMNIT 

  • @alexarandolph she fine.

  • this is not my song!

  • Kelly, you're voice is so beautiful. Girl, you're so good. You're the best singer ever.

  • c ya at mall joe biden!!! we will have a ball at the mall, lol

  • I love you, I am not going to crack. i know nothing; i see nothing :) Dr. Himanshu parikh lol

  • AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

  • :-)

  • who did the orgional of this song?? i need to hear it!!

  • @teamedward232 This is the original as far as i know. Jon McLaughlin and 311 has a song by the same name, but are totally different songs.

  • @teamedward232 Kelly is the original! It's her song. :)

  • this isnt 311 FUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111

  • What a talent!

  • i love u doyle aaron price jr This is a war and we are fighting for a "TIT FOR TAT"

  • tampons and maxipads and pantiliners are a womans curse. women stay away from me if you are bleeding. periods are nasty

  • You should watch this video from the philippines. her name is maricris garcia.. This is her own version of Beautiful Disaster by Kelly Clarkson.

    Just type "Beautiful Disaster- Maricris Garcia

  • i love freemasons

  • thumbs up if Kitty from X-Factor brought you here... :@ RUINER OF SONGS.

  • @bizzmalify She isn't as bad as people think. People just can't see past her controversial personality.

    Put it this way, she is a good singer, who's heart is in all the right places. Unlike Frankie's.

    Also, Lady Gaga is no different, yet she is adored and embraced for her uniqueness.

  • @bizzmalify that's what i was thinking :P I mean i feel bad for her and i'm not a hater, i mean i'm sure she's a nice person and stuff but she sings through her nose! :P

  • @bizzmalify YOU MUMS A RUINER OF SONGS YOU BARSTARD!!! KITTY IS AMAZING !

  • @Possessed2k9 Umm, everyone has an opinion. I don't particually like kitty either but no one should have to read a comment like that so maybe think before you type.

  • such raw emotion a singer who will always be one of the finest singers to come out of a talent show.......

  • @alexarandolph than you will be glad to know she has released a news single "mr know it all"

    

  • kitty shouldnt have sung that song becuase nobody could beat kellys voice :) x

  • @animelover3331 exactly she set herself up for failure...no way near as good as this version!

  • aaron price

  • its been awhile i didn't hear to this song! i used to hear it when my heart was broken down or when i need some comfort..<3

  • 198 people are disasters .. 

  • @mennahsabry ugly disasters 

  • What I like about Kelly Clarkson is that it's evident (especially in a performance such as this) that she is not an auto-tune user. I really think that other pop singers should follow her example.

  • she will make a great mother some day she is precious!!!

  • LOVE this song!

  • Love it

  • this gives me the shivers !!!

  • I only think of River Phoenix when I hear this song...:(

  • oh this isnt 311... dammit

  • @miktu Maybe beacuse you arent on it. LMFAO

  • does anyone have the lyrics to this version ? :) thanks

  • @xxKelseyx3xx its the same as the faster paced version, she just slowed it down. I love this version better.

  • *sniffles* that was beautiful.

  • wow so beautiful!

  • I miss her man.

  • @blingblingshineshine I miss her too! But i found out she has a new song coming out Aug. 30 called Mr. Know It All and then her album Stronger which comes out Oct. 25!!! im so excited shes been goon for way too long lol :)

  • @shannonluzchris omg really??AH :D :D Thank you^^

  • great!!!!

  • this song made me cry... so beautiful

  • where's P-Nut?

  • i love this so much

  • i don't know.. i don't know really...

    could you be my beautiful disaster??? please be my beatiful disaster RJP...

  • the run at 2:08 IS AMAZING.

  • thumbs up if you're looking for Beautiful Disaster by 311 and came across this.....

  • goooosebumbs.

    

  • Kelly's Beautiful! I lok forward to all the song she has yet to sing!

  • 2:07 is by far one of my favorite parts in any song. I love her voice...and her shapely figure :)

    Yeah, she can bare my children.

  • wow she's sings so beautiful i am a little jealous of her voice

  • Love it(;

  • This is an amazing song and she is so good live!! <3

  • She is far from Madonna. Much more rugged and sincere. This is a stunning example.

  • @DaniceBryant49 Where did that comment even come from? Haha!

  • @DaniceBryant49 If you've ever seen her you'll know she is definetely not trying to be Madonna! In fact I'd say she is almost the opposite! Her concerts are literally her and whatever band she needs, no gimics no costume changes no nothing. Unlike Madonna who is Queen of these things.

  • love dis song

  • oh gosh just cant wait for fer 5th album!!!!:)

  • 195 people dont have an heart

  • 195 people are disasters.

  • INTRO ?! ...

  • @CowriahSlutarey You are probably the most terrible person I have ever heard of and your voice will never compare to Kelly Clarkson.

  • r u fuckin kiddin me?

  • ole que pasa que no deja ver todo el videoooo

  • Tune

  • was this when she took part in american idol?or is she appearing on it?

  • @SophieAndSianxD appearing on

  • wow, great performance..

  • she is part Greek anestry

  • DONT CUT THE INTRO, *** !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • she s so nervous though! not that good really! nice tone!

  • who originally sang this

  • LOL I MADE A COVER OF THIS WHEN I WAS LIKE 10 LOL CHECK IT OUT BY TYPIN: Paul Escorrido singing lol!

  • I'm going to her concert for Microsoft at Houston Galleria then to the m&g!!! Super excited!

  • i still love this version better than the cd one. It just shows so much emotions and its so beautiful! just like Kelly!

  • Awesome

  • @alexarandolph

    new album in september :)

  • @alexarandolph The truth is that in a way she can't compete with the garbage that's being poured out onto the radio nowadays. She has her loyal fans, such as myself, but not a lot of other people are going to want to listen to her when they prefer autotuned artists. She can sing, arguably as one of the best singers in the world, but as long as people prefer crap-music she can't keep putting out as many singles as she would like. Besides she just finished recording her new album.

  • @IceMoonPetal kind of glad she is not having to compete with modern "music" she is in a different class..i cant stand the "idol" thing but glad for one kelly ..best thing by a mile from all the seasons all the countries..would love to hear an old school big band album because i actually think she is better than her own music gives credit for..