The tonality of this song deffenately doesn't help Annette, but that does not mean that she doesn't have an incredible voice. These are just not her songs, its like David Draiman singing Cory Taylor's songs.. it just wont sound right.. the new songs kick ass, they show the real beuty of her voice!
WHAT A SHAME....... THIS SONG IS NOT WISHMASTER. Maybe Annette is a good singer (bah...) but she cannot destroy songs as this one in this way... the same destiny for songs as sleeping sun or ever dream. STOP THIS SHAME. She is good only in dak passion ecc... tracks, where nighwish style is less mature. No war, Annette, no war. Just do what u can do, not what you can't.! THE CHILD BLESS THEE AND KEEP THIS FOREVER.
bitch bitch bitch..lets see you guys tour for a year and sound as good as that..this was one of the reason they fired Tarja..she didn't want to go on a real tour - at least Anette can handle it!
they used all the excuses to hide what really happened..we wont ever know the real deal why Nightwish let Tarja go...congrats! you made yourself sound like a moron
because its the truth...the problem is you Anette fans think you know the world...unless you work media then you wouldnt understand and thats th truth
Vibrato is often used as a crutch by singers who cannot sustain a difficult note for more than a second or two. She obviously doesn't have Tarja's vocal range and she knows her voice will crack if she tries to sustain those notes cleanly. ie-iee-iee shit. My fav Nightwish song bastardized. :/
I know this....believe me....I know its destroyed...makes me cry....it has nothing to do with having Tarja's vocal range...it purely has to do with vocal style....if they had a singer like Vibeke Stene singing this....it would be effn amazing but fact is that she isnt classically trained and I dont think they counted on her transposing it like this
"sometimes it sounds a bit like shes in really bad pain "
I know what you mean. In one video where she's trying to sing an old Nightwish song, she starts to wrinkle up her face and squats lower and lower as she tries to hit a set of high notes. It looked like she was trying to give birth on stage, and sounded like it too... LOL!
whatever Poulpate i guess thats why i got paid $800.00 dollars a weekend for my videos working for Nascar!....I used a 3.2mp digital camera with video capabilities....not my $2800.00 dollar Canon GL1 3ccd,so sorry that i didnt please you -NOT.
let me start with anette has a nice voice and sounds really good on the new album but i cant help it when i think that she really shouldnt be singing the old stuff (except for ever dream and a few other songs) because of the extreme power needed to hit and carry the note in the way tarja did (ex end of dead boys poem Fantasmic 3)
The proposal was pretty cool, you rarely see this anymore at concerts. Its nice when bands are willing to do things like that. This was a great show. Anette was flawless on all songs, and I don't care what anyone else says about her. She can sing, if you don't have anything good to say, than keep it to yourself please:).
Hooooly fuck. So they did the marriage proposal afterall, right? Maaan, there was a dude on the forum who was so desperate for that, I'm glad he got what he want. Yea, Marco rocks. :p And so does Anette, thanks for posting :)
Actually, that's not me. I tried Nightmail, but got no response, so I gave a note to Tero before the show starte and he gave it to the band. I never went on the forum. (Using my fiancee's youtube login here, dont have my own). Thanks for the congrats tho.
She will eventually compare BUT not with the power songs. Nemo, etc. This one she actually sounds not too half bad! We should expect to hear some good things from her :)
she asks for someone called Sabrina, then she says someone has something to say to you, then I guess her boyfriend proposed, she accepted and Anette saud "Congratulations, why don't you take a honeymoon to Sahara!"
annette,you are in the toilette..
nnadine1973 2 years ago
oh nouououououououuuuuuu :(
Althreya 2 years ago
The tonality of this song deffenately doesn't help Annette, but that does not mean that she doesn't have an incredible voice. These are just not her songs, its like David Draiman singing Cory Taylor's songs.. it just wont sound right.. the new songs kick ass, they show the real beuty of her voice!
zeramino 2 years ago
its the same music and the same text,m and i mean its wishmaster or????
hosabund 2 years ago 3
WHAT A SHAME....... THIS SONG IS NOT WISHMASTER. Maybe Annette is a good singer (bah...) but she cannot destroy songs as this one in this way... the same destiny for songs as sleeping sun or ever dream. STOP THIS SHAME. She is good only in dak passion ecc... tracks, where nighwish style is less mature. No war, Annette, no war. Just do what u can do, not what you can't.! THE CHILD BLESS THEE AND KEEP THIS FOREVER.
FoxNearby2012AD 2 years ago
omg this song sucks with annette
rocko0333 2 years ago
oh my god this is so bad, i can't stand it.
She destroys the song with her voice. She shold stick to the new songs, they are just as bad as her voice.
Tarja is the best!!!
MrsBWL 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this fucking sucks! anette sucks at this song!! btw...she does at every song...
kusk6y 3 years ago
I love Annette, but she can't sing these kind of musics, so she shouldn't try it.
samingau 3 years ago
the refrain sounds like rap
horrible!!!!!!
This is the worst thing i've ever heard!!
MrsBWL 3 years ago
bitch bitch bitch..lets see you guys tour for a year and sound as good as that..this was one of the reason they fired Tarja..she didn't want to go on a real tour - at least Anette can handle it!
Zorsha 3 years ago
they used all the excuses to hide what really happened..we wont ever know the real deal why Nightwish let Tarja go...congrats! you made yourself sound like a moron
sweetaztecangel69 3 years ago
uhm..congrats you just made yourself out to be an asshole.
And how can you claim they are "hiding" something, when you also claim that we will never really know what happened, all in the same sentence?
Pot, meet Kettle - er, Moron, rather.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
Zorsha 3 years ago
because its the truth...the problem is you Anette fans think you know the world...unless you work media then you wouldnt understand and thats th truth
sweetaztecangel69 3 years ago
uhm....smoking crack is bad for you.
Zorsha 3 years ago
i agree with you
mariaepbj 3 years ago
thank you :] Im just getting tired of Anette fans trying to tell me how to work media when Ive clearly done it for a while :D
sweetaztecangel69 3 years ago
LA Sombra de Tarja Siempre le pesara...
lordluisduran 3 years ago
"Oh elbere-e-e-e-e-eeeeth, oh lóri-e-e-e-e-eeeeen!"
FUCKKK! she should stop that thing of trembling her voice! It's really annoying and sounds terrible!
but in this songs it works, but she does that in EVERY old nw song!
spookybellatrix 3 years ago 2
shes trying to hve a strong a vibrato as Tarja does
sweetaztecangel69 3 years ago
Vibrato is often used as a crutch by singers who cannot sustain a difficult note for more than a second or two. She obviously doesn't have Tarja's vocal range and she knows her voice will crack if she tries to sustain those notes cleanly. ie-iee-iee shit. My fav Nightwish song bastardized. :/
zombies8u 3 years ago 3
I know this....believe me....I know its destroyed...makes me cry....it has nothing to do with having Tarja's vocal range...it purely has to do with vocal style....if they had a singer like Vibeke Stene singing this....it would be effn amazing but fact is that she isnt classically trained and I dont think they counted on her transposing it like this
sweetaztecangel69 3 years ago
:D sometimes it sounds a bit like shes in really bad pain :D no offense
Vikoriaa 3 years ago
"sometimes it sounds a bit like shes in really bad pain "
I know what you mean. In one video where she's trying to sing an old Nightwish song, she starts to wrinkle up her face and squats lower and lower as she tries to hit a set of high notes. It looked like she was trying to give birth on stage, and sounded like it too... LOL!
justanamehere 3 years ago 3
They should have chosen all the less operatic songs for her to sing on their tour..
Sdoppelganger 3 years ago
Hate when she singing songs by Tarja ;(
[sory for my english ;p]
dizzilyy0 3 years ago
In the beginning I hated Anette but the more I hear her sing it becomes very clear to me that
there is no way she can match Tarja BUT there
is ONE thing that Anette does way better than
Tarja and that is singing a lot more cleare
meaning that you can understand the whole text
of the song a thing that was often very hard
to do with Tarja singing.
Heartborne7thSeeker 3 years ago 2
I can actually understand the lyrics! lol
cosmowiz 3 years ago
Tarja is much better for this song!
Sweetiey 3 years ago 4
That outfit is my fucking favorite on her!!!!! =) im waiting for the starland show!! :D im stoked
TheEscapist9257 3 years ago 2
Yeah, stop bashing her! I'd like to see you guys do it better!
Natteoenske 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bad sound and film, you're not a movie maker just stop it....
Poulpate 3 years ago
whatever Poulpate i guess thats why i got paid $800.00 dollars a weekend for my videos working for Nascar!....I used a 3.2mp digital camera with video capabilities....not my $2800.00 dollar Canon GL1 3ccd,so sorry that i didnt please you -NOT.
dabest70 3 years ago
Having actually been to that concert, it wasn't too bad. I mean yes she isn't Tarja, but then again Marco ruled lol...
Siorai67 3 years ago
I have to admit, she is sounding much better than some of her first voice covers of the songs we know so well from Tarja.
GryphonSoul 3 years ago
let me start with anette has a nice voice and sounds really good on the new album but i cant help it when i think that she really shouldnt be singing the old stuff (except for ever dream and a few other songs) because of the extreme power needed to hit and carry the note in the way tarja did (ex end of dead boys poem Fantasmic 3)
findingthekey101 4 years ago
I reckon they wouldn't perform those songs if it wasn't for the fact they're fan favourites...
AndThereTheyWere 3 years ago 2
The proposal was pretty cool, you rarely see this anymore at concerts. Its nice when bands are willing to do things like that. This was a great show. Anette was flawless on all songs, and I don't care what anyone else says about her. She can sing, if you don't have anything good to say, than keep it to yourself please:).
EarthNightIcedWish 4 years ago 4
Bueno, Tarja es Tarja, pero de ahí a decir ieieieie con cada estrofa larga... de todas formas me gusta la voz que tiene Anette =)
Asdianita 4 years ago
Pobre Anette...
vakinhaa 4 years ago
The key has been lowered :O
I remember Wishmaster was sung on a higher note
Cyndane 4 years ago
Hooooly fuck. So they did the marriage proposal afterall, right? Maaan, there was a dude on the forum who was so desperate for that, I'm glad he got what he want. Yea, Marco rocks. :p And so does Anette, thanks for posting :)
WhatIOnceWas 4 years ago
Actually, that's not me. I tried Nightmail, but got no response, so I gave a note to Tero before the show starte and he gave it to the band. I never went on the forum. (Using my fiancee's youtube login here, dont have my own). Thanks for the congrats tho.
samstyres 4 years ago
anette sounds like she is doing karaoke. she is horrible :S
fcaneta 4 years ago
good supervision, on my opinion here she's not nearly tries well to sing
Oomka 4 years ago 2
i agree. shes probably not a bad singer but comparted to tarja she will never compare
OmgzErica 4 years ago
She will eventually compare BUT not with the power songs. Nemo, etc. This one she actually sounds not too half bad! We should expect to hear some good things from her :)
GryphonSoul 3 years ago 2
good job Anette...
vilmaragouv 4 years ago
was marco wearing...nothing but his underwear? gutta luv that guy ! ^^
DarkestWorld 4 years ago 4
I cannot understand what she says =(
Anyway, she is getting better day by day! I love her :D
beabiah 4 years ago 10
I understand her better than I did Tarja... I prefer Tarja in this song BIG TIME, though.
HEDELEX 4 years ago 3
What does she say after the song?
beabiah 4 years ago
she asks for someone called Sabrina, then she says someone has something to say to you, then I guess her boyfriend proposed, she accepted and Anette saud "Congratulations, why don't you take a honeymoon to Sahara!"
maybeshescrazy 4 years ago 3
oh! thank you very much! :D
beabiah 4 years ago 2
ACTUALLY, she asks for someone named Samantha Styres. And I said yes!
samstyres 4 years ago
she's talking to a girl named samanthat (trust me i work with the guy who proposed) and ya she cried :D (good tears) it was exciting
sammysmiles77 4 years ago
crap quality video its nothing to do with Anette so go fuck off
themetalcloud 4 years ago
WHOO HOO!! great marriage proposal!
mystiquesword 4 years ago
Man, Anette gets better and better! Awesome!!
It's sooo cool that someone got Anette to introduce a proposal, and that she did it, too! Awesome!
nekonezume 4 years ago
sounds better and better every time;)
kingaksu 4 years ago
Ok folks the pics are up from this show,
just click on my name to go to my channel
look for (my website) in my personal info.
click on it and then click on view all 104 pics,
then click on NIGHTWISH 10-31-07 Halloween album
feel free to "right click and save as"
you can also use the provided source code to put on web pages.
dabest70 4 years ago