this is the piece that made me fall in love with shostakovich when i was 12 .. <3 . Till this day it remains my favourite waltz to listen + imagine dancing to~
Sure, a composer can call his music anything he wants, but there is nothing "jazz" about this music. Great composer though he was, jazz purists would not call this music jazz, and I tend to agree.
@Tuxster3: All the compositions of the "Big Band" era (see Wikipedia) were written on paper prior to performance. The distinction between classical music and jazz is subtle and slippery. As in many other subjects, a "purist" maintains easy distinctions only by drawing artificial lines that no one else can see. Leonard Bernstein and George Gershwin also romped happily in the borderlands where purists never venture.
Shostakovich could slum with the best of Jazz, but he was Always Shostakovich. Without doubt, the greatest of all 20th century composers, and certainly among the greatest of all-time composers.
Like Bach, Beethoven and the greatest, Shostakovich will live as long as Humanity lives.
@PTCello Wanted to write some words before I read yours. But couldn't be better than yours. But I have to add another two other great names: Gershwin and Ravel.
Yes. I am playing "pavane for a dead princess' on my recital, and Porgy is, after Don Giovanni and the other great Mozart operas, my favorite opera. Such a tragedy that the great Gershwin died at only 36.
On of the most elegant waltzes ever written. Playful and serious at the same time. Simple and with surprises around every corner. Wonderful, pure Shostakovich.
It is okay to some extent that people don't know about Shostakovich (I mean let's not forget him); if they can recognize that the music sounds great, it is all the more testament to the composition, as opposed to respecting a work because we know it's from a great name.
My band just did a transcription/recording of this movt. for trumpet, cello, accordion, and guitar. Planning on finishing out the Suite soon. Love this stuff, its so quirky and wonderful!
Band it called Lulu's Playground if you're interested in hearing it, may post a vid of it soon.
@cacav I never did post a vid, though I have a few somewhere. We did record it though, it plays right away at our website lulusplayground (dot) com. sorry for the delayed reply!
stop with that unknown thing. People who are interested in classic knows the names of Shostakovich, Prokofiev and Rahmaninov as well as those of Bethoven, Mozart and Chopin.
Only heard of mozart and bethoven.... but i've just realized that i've heard quite a few composers besides mozart and bethoven... Just a shame it's most likely from movies.
He's unknown relatively speaking. When people hear russian, they think Tchaikovsky. I love Shastakovich, I was just saying that it's a pity he's not as well known as he should be.
Interesting question: What do you call it when something's appreciated by many, but most of them haven't a clue who created it?
(e.g. the Golden Gate bridge in San Francisco, California; Jazz Suite No. 1). Is such appreciation appreciably lessened by ignorance of the creator's identity and biography?
@kate51035 Why certainly, among the intelligence, but among the more plebeian types that make up the vast bulk of our encounters, they do, unfortunately, not tend to know of such great artists.
Note the stroke of triangle at 1:31; only a genius can change the course of a statement like that! DSCH was a genius and a humanist much like Beethoven. Listen to his symphony number 5 with Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic (1959 recording).
I agree. The Triangle was a wonderful way of changing the melodic idea so suddenly. I've also heard Benstein conducting the Fifth, last movements. Bernsteins interpretation is superb, and he really brings out the specific traits of Shostakovich.
wooow
ChidFreid 1 week ago
this is the piece that made me fall in love with shostakovich when i was 12 .. <3 . Till this day it remains my favourite waltz to listen + imagine dancing to~
13243546abcdef 3 weeks ago
Sure, a composer can call his music anything he wants, but there is nothing "jazz" about this music. Great composer though he was, jazz purists would not call this music jazz, and I tend to agree.
Tuxster3 2 months ago
@Tuxster3: All the compositions of the "Big Band" era (see Wikipedia) were written on paper prior to performance. The distinction between classical music and jazz is subtle and slippery. As in many other subjects, a "purist" maintains easy distinctions only by drawing artificial lines that no one else can see. Leonard Bernstein and George Gershwin also romped happily in the borderlands where purists never venture.
mhdecoursey 1 month ago
@mhdecoursey To the "purists" those "lines" are not artificial and can be seen quite well. So, I tend to agree with the purists.
Tuxster3 1 month ago
wow it certenly must have taken some guts to write a JAZZ suite during stalins rule, in wich jazz was seen as "imperialistic decadent crap"
zhongjinshu1 3 months ago 6
anyone else think of "Up" when they hear this?
abcdeflyer 5 months ago 9
i see images of the western front in 1916 when i hear this
Overlorddz 6 months ago
Lindíssima!!
311960 6 months ago
This music reminds me of " The Godfather"
joraca267 7 months ago
I pity the lonely disliker.
thumanina 7 months ago 8
You can watch the video in the videoresponse for a better version of this masterpiece
89Notsonice 7 months ago
this is cock
Hardiment123 7 months ago
@Hardiment123 Back into your hole pleb.
Daemoni 7 months ago
@atabikomnets: he's Rather unknown in the U.S.? Well my friend many things are unknown in the U.S. but guess what...whose fault is that?
Jerksound 8 months ago 3
One of the best composers ever, and definitely one of my favourites....
getlost0204 8 months ago
Shostakovich could slum with the best of Jazz, but he was Always Shostakovich. Without doubt, the greatest of all 20th century composers, and certainly among the greatest of all-time composers.
Like Bach, Beethoven and the greatest, Shostakovich will live as long as Humanity lives.
PTCello 9 months ago 7
@PTCello Wanted to write some words before I read yours. But couldn't be better than yours. But I have to add another two other great names: Gershwin and Ravel.
DucdeGramont 6 months ago
@DucdeGramont
Yes. I am playing "pavane for a dead princess' on my recital, and Porgy is, after Don Giovanni and the other great Mozart operas, my favorite opera. Such a tragedy that the great Gershwin died at only 36.
PTCello 6 months ago
♥Shostakovich♥
stomvi97 9 months ago
Bach will be dancing in his grave
COMMUNISTPHILOSOPHY 9 months ago
♪♥♫♥♪ :-D
KAT3721 10 months ago 3
This is how I like to see it, no dislikes :D
quickaswink 10 months ago
I have to dance to this song in my ballet class for our recital
starfruit1231 11 months ago
Copy and paste: "Gustavo Dudamel / SBYOV Shostakovich Symphony 10.mvt I 3/4"
superblindados 11 months ago
Masterpiece!
chicosa100 1 year ago
who is the pianist?
FlyingBanana1024102 1 year ago
The man is my hero for what he created and what he endured
northerbrewer 1 year ago
the intro reminds me of Howl's Moving Castle!
i enjoy his works very much though =).
Yamahazryn 1 year ago
On of the most elegant waltzes ever written. Playful and serious at the same time. Simple and with surprises around every corner. Wonderful, pure Shostakovich.
Xylotonic 1 year ago 5
Uh, not well known in the US? Exactly which US are you living in? Sorry, but that's about the most preposterous statement I've read in a while.
Shaojian 1 year ago 3
shostakovich is well known enough for his music to be used for the bbc proms...
123yayicancount 1 year ago 3
i love that music
mademoisellefull 1 year ago
My life would be so dull in the mornings with at The Jazz suite's!
doctorwhom01 1 year ago
I played this one...such a beautiful memory
SydVirgo 1 year ago 2
Hauntingly beautiful. I love Shostakovich's music.
Fergophone 1 year ago 2
@Fergophone
Please, what hauntingly?
meusisto 1 year ago
It is okay to some extent that people don't know about Shostakovich (I mean let's not forget him); if they can recognize that the music sounds great, it is all the more testament to the composition, as opposed to respecting a work because we know it's from a great name.
SirMeowMeow 1 year ago 2
My band just did a transcription/recording of this movt. for trumpet, cello, accordion, and guitar. Planning on finishing out the Suite soon. Love this stuff, its so quirky and wonderful!
Band it called Lulu's Playground if you're interested in hearing it, may post a vid of it soon.
mecklera 1 year ago
@mecklera did you upload any?
cacav 1 year ago
@cacav I never did post a vid, though I have a few somewhere. We did record it though, it plays right away at our website lulusplayground (dot) com. sorry for the delayed reply!
mecklera 11 months ago
stop with that unknown thing. People who are interested in classic knows the names of Shostakovich, Prokofiev and Rahmaninov as well as those of Bethoven, Mozart and Chopin.
inhmn 2 years ago 8
Only heard of mozart and bethoven.... but i've just realized that i've heard quite a few composers besides mozart and bethoven... Just a shame it's most likely from movies.
krabbe88 2 years ago
@krabbe88 american?
Comprised 1 year ago
@Comprised European.
krabbe88 1 year ago
@krabbe88 neither Russian
sreknoy 1 year ago
The glory of the russian-soviet music, when the silence was the law, and the music was a form of philosophy...DD Schostakovich...
pablovasconezm 2 years ago
Ahh... Shastakovich, the great unknown Russian Hero...
Jragir 2 years ago 8
He is certainly not unknown!
Think before you say something
kate51035 2 years ago 78
He's unknown relatively speaking. When people hear russian, they think Tchaikovsky. I love Shastakovich, I was just saying that it's a pity he's not as well known as he should be.
Jragir 2 years ago 9
Under-appreciated, not unknown.
BrucknerMotet 2 years ago 10
Interesting question: What do you call it when something's appreciated by many, but most of them haven't a clue who created it?
(e.g. the Golden Gate bridge in San Francisco, California; Jazz Suite No. 1). Is such appreciation appreciably lessened by ignorance of the creator's identity and biography?
BrucknerMotet 2 years ago 2
@kate51035 Why certainly, among the intelligence, but among the more plebeian types that make up the vast bulk of our encounters, they do, unfortunately, not tend to know of such great artists.
pookiehohn 2 years ago 7
@pookiehohn Why, aren't you an insufferable snob.
Gonnakillyou 1 year ago
@kate51035
he's Rather unknown in the U.S. , i don't like this but that's the reality.
atabakimoments 1 year ago
@atabakimoments If you say so. I am not from the USA :)
kate51035 1 year ago
@kate51035 he is indeed unknown to those that do not know of him
COMMUNISTPHILOSOPHY 9 months ago 3
me too...
pelageja56 2 years ago
This reminds me of Fellini movies.
aesthetic1950 2 years ago 8
Interesting that this waltz is almost completely identical to the waltz of Ballet Suite No. 1 (with a few modifications). Both are wonderful works.
DannyDaWriter 2 years ago
we are playing this for our marching band show this year. This is the second out of three years we are playing shostakovich. Cool stuff.
EDGJZConglomerate 2 years ago
this is similar to the second Waltzes but it's not at the same time
yashil17 2 years ago 2
i play it in the trombone..
fortissimo94 3 years ago
Note the stroke of triangle at 1:31; only a genius can change the course of a statement like that! DSCH was a genius and a humanist much like Beethoven. Listen to his symphony number 5 with Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic (1959 recording).
Neishapour 3 years ago 8
I agree. The Triangle was a wonderful way of changing the melodic idea so suddenly. I've also heard Benstein conducting the Fifth, last movements. Bernsteins interpretation is superb, and he really brings out the specific traits of Shostakovich.
Strad615 2 years ago 6
Shostakovich!is my HERO!
johnnynoirman 3 years ago 51
Awesome!
carissia1910 3 years ago 4
He did what he wanted. XD
I love Shostakovich!
Lotrompetista 3 years ago 2
I love these harmonies- seemless, yet out of the blue!
skryabyn 3 years ago 3
Congratulations! Great music!
Eddlap 3 years ago 4