Added: 2 years ago
From: dennyfromspace
Views: 130,661
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (349)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • If you didn't know... the US government today released a statement on the subject of "alien contact" i suggest you follow the story, in short they said they have made no contact what so ever and there's no evidence for other worldly life as yet, even independent UFO researchers said today that there was no evidence for a cover-up, I've told you all before why you got the "saucer crash" story which spawned 60 years of myth, they are telling you the truth today, but not the whole truth.

  • I heard "Wunderwaffen" and immediately thought of Dr. Edward Richtofen.

  • The guys in the show are pretty much at the mercy of the History Channel. They have lots of footage you will never see aired. Don't blame them, blame the "powers that be" for limiting the real evidence. The "truth" is NOT on TV.

  • I laughed so hard when I saw the english subtitle of an english speaking german..

  • THIS IS A FUCKING COMEDY RIGHT!

  • we are not alone in this universe.our guardians and creator design us to think fast but someone are holding us to see the reality.so,we are blinded from that truth that we are highly engineered for a certain task,to obey.

  • you got to wonder at a retired air force guy giving this out to the history channel and having the backstory of seeing them as a kid

  • This is for fucking little kids and primitive fat fucks...

  • The nazi's were strangely a little more opened minded in a lot of fields thats why they were years ahead, oh that and a good supply of slaves :P why u think america invades iraq and stuff .. oil ,cheap labour etc etc etc ... the only freedom america wants u too have is which american product to buy :)

  • Second part???? & all parts??

  • Robert Jungk wrote "Brighter Than A Thousand Suns". He's a respected Physics historian. He says Germany flew these things in 1945.They went over 2500mph in early tests. He lists the developers, says one came to the USA, one to Russia. And I believe him. The Acorn shaped UFO's, like at Texburg UFO (sp) 1965 and the one near Needles. Colorado Rv,2008, are 2 such UFO"s.

  • @GermanEfficiency ....So.....50.0001% of ALL inventions are German. When your passport says your eyes are brown..... they aren't, you are just full of shit right to the brim.

  • @GermanEfficiency FACTS: (because caploc makes your FACTS more factual)

    The Allies developed the Abomb.

    The British developed the jet engine at the same time as Germany.....not 25 years later.

    The B2 is NOT based on a German design, it could not have been developed without CAD.

    The world we enjoy today is the result of a few German scientists selling themselves to the West and a lot of German scientists wasting resources on stupid ideas so the Allies won the war faster.

  • It is also believed that the Germans during WW2 searched for the "hollow earth" and found it a bit later around 1947-1948. Hollow earth civilizations are known to be so technologically advanced. Search "hollow Earth" I'm still not sure as to believe it or not myself.

  • I find it funny that they keep using the arbitrary "Germans were 25 years ahead". Bear in mind, the Allies had invented the Abomb, jet engine, TV guided bomb, RADAR, etc. The only area the Germans were really ahead in was rocketry.

  • Nazi's known flying objects.

  • Classified Salvage Destroyed By Military I don't Think So

  • And Where Did The Nazi Scientists Get The Technology From Surely Not Human Technology ?

  • Why Do The USA Have The Space Fighter Shuttle X-43A That's A bit weird and why do the Russian's Have Russian Space Forces What are full Of Spacemen Who Are Trained To carry Out Combat Operations In Space It's A bit weird But New Movie Movie Coming Out In 4.4.2012 Called Iron Sky Its About Nazi Moon Bases watch the trailers.

  • what the hell... wunderwaffe? thats in nazi zombies on call of duty!!!!

  • This is whats known as the tail wagging the dog, ufologists love these kinds of programs because it gives an earthly validation to their UFO myth, what they don't see is the 'wood for the trees' because the simple truth is, UFOs are not being covered up, they ARE the cover up.. the 'spaceships' were rockets and the 'aliens' all illegal German one imported illegally into the US under a secret operation, this is why the public got the made up story "saucer crash" thus the UFO myth was born...

  • BTW, if anyone compare the first UFO sighting ever in USA with modern day weaponry... you can clearly see that UFO is actually a test plane or prototype of B2 bomber... as I assume everyone knows about Operation Paperclip... and i'd say we got the fact now...

  • @Vostadues tes, paperclip is the real reason for the US sanctioned misdirection story of "saucer crash" but this cover story was too sensational in the press and did the reverse...attract the public towards the area, so it was all down-graded and demystified to 'weather balloon' for public consumption and so that all those ex-Nazi's living and working in the deserts of New Mexico could go about their business for the US military, these are desperate UFO TV shows close to the real truth... :)

  • shows better than i expected...

    -open minded

    -skeptical

    -they think UFOs are cool but they only exist after hard evidence

  • daaaaimn now there are space nazis.....

  • @eLaTeSniping

    God why don't you cry more

  • My people are convinced that little brother has forgotten where his roots lie, you should be proud and support these small group of our white brothers whose eyes are begining to open, for they indeed speak the truth even though what they see is sometimes the Father in Wasingtons attempt to combine the truth, which is hardly believable, though true with the unknown which can not be proven because they(E.B.E.)s do not want the public to know, the Gov. has no choice but to comply..we know this....

  • when one of the most important events that has happened since they first arrived, it is foolish even from a scientific standpoint, to dismiss such evidence as shit, unbelieveable, or not worth investigation really shows the lack of open mindedness that will be required to fully understand what is happening. And as a Native American whose own tribe has verbal stories predating contact about the existance and reture of these starpeople, I assure you that things are stranger than you can imagine.

  • I remember when the History Channel used to be about history.

  • @inademv ufos are history :/ and this is history

  • Let them go into area 51

  • claro que os americanos sabem tudo sobre isso , são eles por tras de tudo isso,só uma criança não sabe disso..

  • God I love hearing Germans speak English

  • does bill have eyes?

    i mean, i have never seen thenm on camera

  • i was playing WoW at 8 pm when my friend started to scream UFO... i laughed so hard then when i looked out of the window i saw a circle orange UFO.. he was moving left and right.. up and down.. which is impossible for an aircraft.. i know alot of u guys wont believe this..

  • CHECK OUT "2012 UFOs Connections and Revelations" ON YOUTUBE This is a

    compilation of evidence revealed by former and present American

    presidents, astronauts, military personnel, politicians along with

    credible aired UFO footage. This compilation also contains planned

    revelations regarding knowledge of life beyond Earth along with it's

    current and ever ongoing presence which is being hidden from the public.

    This knowledge has been hidden from the public for over 50 years. +

    MORE.

  • God the history channel has really gone to shit....

  • @EzKrispy

    THIS SHIT IS REAL

  • This youtube user is the son of an ex NAZI war criminal and spreads properganda on youtube: Betamax101

  • Two kinds of UFO: 1) Psalm 68:17 The chariots of GOD are myriads, thousands upon thousands; The Lord is among them as at Sinai, in holyness.

    2) Rev 13 :2 The dragon(Greys=Fallen Angels) gave the beast(Govnmts war industry) his power(alien technology) and his throne(militar supremacy) and great authority(mass control intel).4 People worshiped the dragon ... and they also worshiped the beast and asked, “Who is like the beast(Army)? Who can wage war against it?

  • OMG look at 7:04! A little white alien lands on his jacket and tries to control his brain!

  • VRIL

  • I dont like this show because they dont hunt shit they get al these stories on ufo's but at the end of it they didn't prove shit just leaves questions

  • *cough*bullshit*cough*

  • wunderwaffen what about the wunderwaffe

  • great video

  • That old guy with the glasses is a moron.

  • Comment removed

  • @eliasrio its spelt Holyness.... geez..

  • @Jakzerstoren thanks buddy, was late and I slipped !

  • @semmie1000 Check out "Pirates of the Caribbean,Dead Mans Chest."part 11 here on the tube.At 6:40,you can see the UFO to the left of the screen.It moves behind her head and flies off to the right.I was blessed to find this in the DVD movie a few years ago.It is very much clearer in the DVD.Check it out and let me know what you think.Tell everyone you know.I think this could be a first.

  • recent UFO are flown by skinheads. 

  • 4:43 a steam air ship? lol

  • germans are known for their sence of humor, they probebly figured out that it would be a good parting gift for the allies, to get them in panic about an alian invasion lol

  • hiihiiihhihihihihihhi

  • OMFG WUNDDER WAFFEE COME TO MEH MY MINONS

  • blinky bill will believe ANYTHING, christ! He believes ppl are hybrids, that aliens were experimenting on humans and other aliens, while working alongside humans?!?!? just cuz someone said it. Even pat pulls back some times, jesus. but pat buddy, you're awesome in my book, seem like a great guy, a gentleman of a huge dork, but take off the damn hat bro!!! for once! ur like bill with the jacket and shades. by the way, ive seen EVERY episode. the only show i like more than this is ancient aliens

  • so trearch wonderwaffen weapon in WAW is real or is this just a satelite and it is it really a coicendence that a meteoright just happenes to land in Tunguski right after the war I THINK NOT

  • CHECK OUT MY VIDEO

    EVIDENCE THAT "DIE GLOCKE" IS STILL BEING TESTED

  • In the 30's and 40's anti-gravity was in the media alot something with mercury. also they couldn't fire or drop anything from the ufo's or it will destroy there gravitational field. The field of energy produced loses energy when landing on ground (grounding out) and it takes time to recharge. USA and Russia were first to copy this and we made them in Brazil blonde hair blue eye people would pilot these sometimes they'd land and people would come out and aliens are blonde hair blue eye etc.

  • There are ufo designs on the masonic apron of george washington and that was in the 1700's

  • If we germans wouldn´t be so good engineers, the world war would have already ended after one year lol^^

  • Why does it stop at 1:57

  • 1 or 2 more years of the war and we would all be speaking German.

  • WunderWaffe is pronounced the VunderVaffe.

  • mazi's are cool :D besides killing jew's

  • If you guys have today those "COOOL" guns, guided misiles, jet planes, v shaped bombers, assault rifles, rocket launchers (panzerfaust and panzerschreck), and many, many more amazing weapons is because your government.... let´s say... "ADOPTED" those technollogies and "WELCOMED" in a very gallant way those poor german scientists who made them.

  • WonderWaffen in Cod W@W Zombie mode???

  • @wendit35 what

  • @wendit35

    Yes, Nazi Zombies mode was based off of true events. The Nazis wanted more power, so they made and tested science fiction like weapons that could win the war for them. They supposedly made the WunderWaffe, and it, supposedly, successfully worked.

  • this is just a load of poor commercial crap. And yes, technologically the Germans kicked ass, no aliens were involved.

  • I love this show

  • type 'changing project video archive' in google and find out more, hundreds of video's are shown their...

  • NAZEH ZOMBEHS

  • I know a german from back in the day and I can tell you, she is resilient and I can see why German were bad asse dback in the day. Ambitious und driven. I highlt admire these creations tthat are ahead of our time. Her uncle worked with Tesla crating the unbelievable. I love U.S. of A but it is true tthat the stuff America has is based upon German inventions from 1940's Nazi Germany. TRuth is thruth. GROW! it's fun dont block yourself! Those guys mins were from somwhere else straight up!

  • i now know what is going on at AREA 51, the Nazi scientist are there. They are the one's experimenting with space crafts. That explains all this UFO stuff, those same scientist that Hitler hired back in the cold war are now at area 51 and other remote locations experimenting.

  • They invented blow job also.

  • Comment removed

  • Well,the model Hitler designed resembled a cross between a Dalek and a missle.

  • @Stuttgart33, hear me out here, bud.

    FACT: The Germans were inventing and in fact did invent workable as well as proto-type wonder weapons - From the first jet fighter to the first assault rifle! Not to mention the first smart bomb, surface-to-air missile, and guidance systems.

    QUESTION: Does it seem more likely that they, the Nazi regime and their engineers, are behind the creation of "flying disks" and "bell" aircraft considering the explosion of "sightings" occur just after WW2?

    YES

  • @1stLtDavis They didn't create shit. Flying disks sigthings are way older than that fool.

  • @dolphusbanks, yeah, that's what they want you to think....just like the U.S. government denied that the nazis were working on any of this shit and admitted in the 70's that from the 50's - 60's they purposefully engaged in deception and helped fan the ridiculous conspiracy that little green men have been kidnapping people, etc.

  • @1stLtDavis The nazi saucer was wobbly as hell lol.

  • @dolphusbanks, what nazi saucer? I've never heard anyone definitively say that there was a successful test during the war. Successful test flights would have most likely come in the first few years post-war, with the majority of the German scientists settled in the South, South-West......which they were.

  • @1stLtDavis Project Y used nazi ideas .

  • @1stLtDavis still doesn't rule out extraterrestrial help

  • @MrJeffFort, But how and why would any creatures know that our planet is even active?

    We've been sending out radio signals into space for a mere 70-80 years.....that bubble of radio and now TV is only 70-80 light years from earth.

    To the vast majority of the galaxy, our planet appears to be totally silent and lifeless.

  • @1stLtDavis not only that, it's a fact that at least 10,000 nazi scientists were smuggled out of europe by the CIA in "Operation Paperclip" after the fall of the Reich. Which is also when UFO sightings started happening.

  • @1stLtDavis FACT: your a dick

  • @TheRobbins12,

    QUESTION: Why are you so dumb and gay?

    FACT: Because you like shitty dicks and your mom is also your sister.

    Got that, bubba?

  • @1stLtDavis anddd the a bomb!

  • Comment removed

  • @pcvideogamer The flying saucer and delta wing designs that were spotted were German designs...and I have no doubt that people saw them....they were very real designs, after all.

    They were, however, military projects of the thousands of Nazis brought to the US and granted immunity for any crimes they may have committed, etc.

  • Comment removed

  • @pcvideogamer Not all of them worked on rockets!

    Most of the Operation Paperclip engineers had been working on planes, guns, and tanks.

    Of course the Germans designed the first flying saucer and delta wing prototypes.....just google Alexander Lippisch, Viktor Chauberger, and the Horten Brothers.

  • @1stLtDavis Horten Stealth bomber :) yeah i know of it... hey, here's a thing... wanna know why the Germans didn't have much to do with so called "flying saucers"? or rather actually made any... because they filmed everything, even the ultra secret V2 yet not ONE video EVER of a flying disk or saucer :) thats why... There's a very good reason why we put the Nazi's together with UFOs (so called) Saucers and Nazis... hmmm, this program was close but no cigar :)

  • @1stLtDavis This program even at the start we see at 0:30 a water-tower used in the production plants either for V2's or whatever, not a bloody UFO launching pad haha, this program is what you get if you give the public a UFO story and allow them to track down its source but without actually letting them know the whole truth and watching them miss-fire completely which just adds to the entire fantasy of it all... entertainment at best, interesting... but they are wrong, shame really.

  • Comment removed

  • @pcvideogamer A flying saucer would need a device like this because it's designed to operate per the Coanda Effect....ie within the atmosphere of the planet.

    A V2 rocket is a ballistic missile

  • @1stLtDavis As this program shows, the misidentification of a 'water-tower' as a launching station or holding site for a Nazi flying disk should give you a fair indication that the compass like instrument as shown at the start of this program might as well be longingly misidentified also.

  • @1stLtDavis One of the things i find most interesting about this program is the place it finds itself, with their tireless quest to find... the truth... they are lead inexorably to the very reasons why the UFO myth was started by the US authorities and will also inevitably lead to the ultimate dead-end conclusion... that they will never find the answers they seek on the UFO subject as they all blindly stare into the void left by 60 years of misinformation and distortions.

  • @pcvideogamer That's an interesting and sound conclusion you've come to,but I'm not sure if you're saying that all UFO claims are hoaxes, or all UFO claims are man-made,secret government craft.If it's the first you're completely wrong.If it's the second,than mankind is a whole hell of a lot more advanced than we're letting on lol cause I'm assuming you've actually done serious research into the subject of UFOs before you came to your conclusion

  • Comment removed

  • @pcvideogamer exactly, and if they wanted real truth all they would have to do is take their HD very expensive cameras and jsut camp out and watch the sky, and im sure they would catch something better tahn alll the footage they collect...

  • @pcvideogamer but it does make for good tv, and i guess tehy are trying to investigate everything, so they can connect and uncover a cover up...i think that is their goal...but i wish they would tyr to get more UFO footage with their cameras

  • @1stLtDavis Actually UFO sightings Occurred in The18th,17th and so on Century Some Historical Text And Images And Scripts Proves it that people did encounter UFO's and ET'S The Reason why The sightings where not recorded Because It was not the 20th Century It was a time where There Was no TV And Other Sources That could spread information easily Unlike todays news agencies and sources a Good Documentary To watch is Ancient Aliens.

  • @Makaveli175 so what you've effectively stated is that there is little or no evidence.

    If you want to believe that little green men have been visiting earth for thousands of years for no reason, that's your prerogative.

    I, however, am interested in what we know for fact, such as the fact the Nazis worked on this technology and that these same egineers came to work for the US.

    Also, that the US AirForce admitted to fanning the flames of UFO and LGM conspiracy during the Cold War.

  • Comment removed

  • @Makaveli175 yeah just seen it, horrible, all woo-woo conjecture and mostly pie in the sky stuff, tail wagging the dog, a program for ufologists with an already active interest in UFOs, very biased, non-scientific clap trap, i can see why it would excite the feeble minded, those already engaged in such theories are easy targets for this type of thing, desperately trying to find a history to their beliefs to legitimatize their faith in UFOs, got anything else? I'm interested, thanks

  • @1stLtDavis The german scientist who after the war went to design the apollo rockets for nasa literally said "we had help from them", pointing in the sky, when some american scientist asked him how it was possible germany was so much more technologically advanced than the allies.

  • @Hanske90 Yeah, about that....after they were here, working for the US government which has come clean that they helped fan the flames of bullshit UFO hysteria in the 50's to keep the retarded public guessing as to what these planes were doing.

  • Aw Ze wunderwaffle how iv missed u

  • acting is terrible lol

    

  • Bill is an Extraterrestrial Alien thats why he always use glasses! LOL

  • A puzzle or two about the compass: 1 Was it actually "classified" and if so, why? This is, if I'm not mistaken, a repeater compass and not anything unique or mysterious. 2 The airforce vet who obtained it said he saw UFOs making 30 degree changes of course and since the compass face is divided into 30 degree increments ipso facto, the compass must be associated with UFOs. So if a UFO wants to make a course correction of 29 degrees or 111 degrees it can't because the compass won't allow it?

  • Comment removed

  • @twobluehorses Disregarding the vet's reasoning, is real, used on the first Nazi's UFO in service

    A Lighter Than Air balloon with a "sombrero" an small cabin under, and two jet engines for propulsion

    To turn they applied more thrust to one of the engines

    Were use for recognizance, people saw UFOs and nobody believed them, and if somebody did was thinking Martians no Germans

    The compass divided in 30 degrees relates to its maximum safe turn capability

    What he saw in 1953 is a further development.

  • UFO hunters is cool, however 3 of their investigations that I've seen so far are proven not extraterrestrials. Still cool, that's totally amazing!!!

  • dudes did that guy said wonderwaffer if he did then i knew that shit was based on a real weapon just like i call of duty world at war nazi zombies

  • @mrgregorygarcia

    retarded thats a game wunderwaffen or wunderwuff means miracle weapon or super weapon in german you 8 year old kid

  • Its stupid to mean that all in the third reich was automaticly Nazis,the most was people they want to win the war,the soviets would win the war,the allies,english and german.

  • Bill looks like a fag in the intro video!!!!!

  • Hahaha ohhh it has to be Occam's razor, sooo in other words, if you're thinking outside the box, too bad, it's wrong? FUCK YOU, Occam's razor , fuck that shit, that rule is horse shit.

  • Does anyone know why they cancelled this show.

  • @orangekeivon jewish viewers were pissed after this episode and you know how they run hollywood so they made a few calls and cancelled it.. :(

  • awh i knew nazis wernt all bad :)

  • So Nasa was founded by Nazis? says it all......

  • Don't think knowing the story behind Nazi Zombies makes you know anything, you don't know shit!

  • The KGB stole my underwear!!!!! It had skid marks in it with traces of element 115!!!!!!!

  • i thought that the wunderwaffen existed in call of duty.

  • funny thing is every thing from Nazi zombies is real because the Tunguska event of 1908 was real and they called the element element 115 and that element could regenerate flesh also the wunderwaffe from nazi zombies is supposedly in area 51 but they are hiding it and the photos from the map de riese Real place the photos are blurred thats because they are real because treyarch payed area51 for all this because they wanted to make this game good the black ops is coming out be prepared for more

  • @CrysoFairy u actually think the government would allow to be bribed for a fuckin video game? over top secret equipment and files?? cmon get real

  • @ZAC2994 do you know anything about the NWO and shit? They like to play mind games pal, why do you think in like 1997 the Xfiles had a show about some terrorists flying RC Airliners into the WTC? Coincidence? Fuck that shit

  • I created the ufo

    

  • Made in Germany you know the Germans always always make good stuff.

  • ive seen ufo's before.. October 31, 1999 at 9 pm Manila time.. 11 lights formation just passed the roof of our house.. they are real.

  • omg nazi ufo's the jews worst fear come too life !!!!!! D :

  • @ReidHarris7 guess who built the nazi's first ufo....

  • this is cool

  • loose the glasses old man before u trip an break a hip or something cause u cant see / an yur really cool when yu wear them in side lol

  • the nazis were far ahead of their time

  • I love ufo hunters, fake or real - interesting information

  • Before anybody rants about the all

    Moving tail plane being US, Miles aircraft fitted one to a trainer in Britain during the war. America and Britain did an exchange of supersonic research after the war in which we gave up the AMT. It was a bad deal as the US had done no supersonic research!

  • Balls they were 25 years ahead. They were about five years ahead on liquid fuelled rockets and cruise missiles. Their radar was level or slightly inferior to British radar. Their atomic weapon research was actually in a cul de sac and would not have ended with a working weapon. Jet engine research was level or slightly ahead of British research. They did develop the swept wing, but Britain thought up the all moving tail plane.

  • reminds me of nazi zombies map pack 3

  • stupid shit

  • Hitler was heavily into the occult,he gained higher knowledge from the demonic realm.Nephilim (Fallen Angels) possess this knowledge and have been teaching man since the beginning of time.

    Hitler attempted a New World Order guided by these entities,a bid to wipe out all and have his own race.After WWII it is said that he escaped along with some of these craft and many Arian's to a secret location in Antarctica.

    Many have had close encounters with Nordic entities who pilot these craft...

  • AHHH NAZI ZOMBIES

    NO a man with the wanderwaffon

  • ufo is a green gay guy thats trying to steel our wemon aka thay r shets

  • The UFOs these witnesses describe are usually about as stealthy as a pink Caddillac. Bright lights, weird displays, and manuvers you can' miss.

  • What a bunch of bullshit...

  • Area 51s element 115 is used in the wunderwaffle and metioned many times in nazi zombies

  • Space Nazi´s must die!=)

  • Lol, they should have made a Nazi UFO instead of Nazi Zombies.

  • @AirShark95, Or Space Zombie Nazis on UFOs.

  • @ArchArturo lol, wtf! =D

  • I have always waited for this.

  • I love the intro..the effects and music is great.

  • Compass for use on u-boats ,still use them today in autosteering device for steel ships ,but i think you can use them on a magnetic electro propulsion craft to!!

  • i laughed at the name haha and still am, but this is a very cool video and i love this show.

  • this is just a TV programme, it had me, but now here your chance to excape the brainwash box, one love. god.

  • @SkrewLooseRecordz wheres ur evidence that theres a man in a chair magically healing people .god is the biggest sin of all.. if u dont believe in me ile destroy your soul and insinerate your skin and send you to hell . not much difference from ADOLF HITLER. u have a life and u certanly dont need god telling u that having sex without marriage shall kill u... BS! relief your life from a book of total bollocks and shit . you HAVE A FUCKING LIFE .wanna play cards oh no. im sorry u cant ...

  • There are areas of the earth where conventional compasses dont work very well - the poles - is this such a big mystery after all? There is always the key element of evidence missing from these programmes. They never fully answer the puzzles they raise. To believe this I need more than hearsay and an old analogue compass!

  • What the vril guy said is absolutely right, check out bill meier

  • Any compass that uses the north star (celestial navigation) as a guide is for use at the north pole (or south pole) regions, where ordinary compasses don't work.

  • excellent video....thanks for posting

  • I published this video on the Dutch website WELSTIJL (18 march) Kind regards Sem Mallée

  • Very interesting video, thanks

  • Hello, i think the creators of this video/TV show might be leading you (unwittingly) in the wrong direction, they ask the question, "What has Nazi's got to do with UFOs?" they even show you a V2 rocket launch from white sands missile range in New Mexico, but what they are not telling is why the US military of the day just after WW2 told the public (oops silly military) they found a flying disk or rather meaning a spaceship of some kind, the answer is simple, can i share with you my thoughts?