He is absolutely correct.. The conductor is just there to give interpretation, keep everyone together and many times the conductor is the worst musician in the room
@maxbigazzi I thought it was the opposite of snobbery. He was humbling himself in comparison to the task set upon the orchestra. Perhaps his tone is didactic, but that's because he teaching a lesson.
What an embarassment for the CSO. Like we don't have good doctors in Chicago to deal with his issue. He should have honored his commitment to the city but the CSO looks like a bunch of morons
Great words from this famous Maestro: ...more and more I less believe in what the conductors can do ... because this is a race what should be disappeared...
I do not have the score. And, can't understand the modulation he is discussing at 2:07 does anyone know the chords is discussing with the note C in common?
@FabioGhibli Thank you for the interpretation. I remember "discovering" that progression. I was about 10 years of age and drove everyone in the house mad by playing it over and over.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Muti is right. He is irrelevant. The first moment when he shoud be helping the woodwinds with tempo, he runs his hand through his hair. Then, instead of concentrating on the woodwinds, he turns the page of his score and is late in giving the cue to the violins, who of course , having no conductor, are on auto pilot and don't breathe as a good conductor would remind them to. Then we get an oratorio from Muti as to why the orchestra can do it alone! But they didn't didn't they?
I am a conductor, and you are 100-% correct. Muti has ruined opera singing, taking away the technical necessity of portamento (no, it's NOT a matter of "taste," it's a technical necessity!) and in this video blathers on about what is musically important without helping the orchestra s ingle bit. Bah! Egomaniac!
According to a great finnish conductor and teacher Jorma Panula one of the most important things is not to disturb the orchestra! When it's going well, so let it flow.
He said also to us playing in the orchestra: dont mind this gesture, it's only for the audience.
@50MusicMan Yes, this was also one of the preferred suggesting of Karajan; he used to say «if they know what to do and they do it alon, don't disturb!»
Viva l'Italia!
thevenot1919 1 month ago
He is very candid..., and humorous.
Curatica 2 months ago
He is absolutely correct.. The conductor is just there to give interpretation, keep everyone together and many times the conductor is the worst musician in the room
theviol93 4 months ago
at the 0:20 ''E' molto importante questo This fraseggio From...'' ahahah he is too much italian!!! Grande Muti !!!
mecrius 4 months ago
@mecrius ha detto "passage". He is truly inspiring, and yes very italian too.
amuiatuncia 3 months ago
the people who dislike this video don't know how to relate to orchestras...
this is lesson number one for any conductor. thank you, jognstubbs52, for posting this!
allthatclassical 5 months ago
a bit too snobby
maxbigazzi 5 months ago
@maxbigazzi I thought it was the opposite of snobbery. He was humbling himself in comparison to the task set upon the orchestra. Perhaps his tone is didactic, but that's because he teaching a lesson.
willsultan 4 months ago
@willsultan
It's just an impression, I don't know him personally. Of course there is no doubt about hi professionalism!
maxbigazzi 4 months ago
il maestro
AlessioSnaporaz 9 months ago
"I am more than 50 years old and in a few years I will retire..."
Chicago is very glad he didn't! We're thrilled to have him!
choirfreak26 10 months ago 2
What piece are they playing? He mentions Mascagni, but . . .
DeeTrumpet 1 year ago
@DeeTrumpet Dvorak 7(?) Pretty sure its 7
kupo150 10 months ago
@kupo150 It's Dvorak's Symphony no. 5.
tss1011 9 months ago
@DeeTrumpet It's from the 1st movement of Dvorak's Symphony no. 5.
tss1011 9 months ago
@johnstubbs52
I'm a conducting student and i would appreciate it if I can have a copy of this video.
eocciano@yahoo.com
Thank you very much.
rikiochs 1 year ago
What a talent. What an ego IN CHECK!!! Unlike Dudamel et al, this guy is all about the music. Mille grazie, maestro
CCConservatory 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Amazing video!!! I would love to have the full copy, can you send it to me as well please?
alexandrasoumm@hotmail.com
thank you so much!
Alexandrasoumm 1 year ago
am looking for a music that's called chavalry charge Ricardo Muti can anyone help me ?
Thank You
albo4ever777 1 year ago
Hi John, Could you also be so kind to send me the fully copy of it too? my address is salehektachrome@yahoo.com. I would appreciate it much :-)
fouadation 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What an embarassment for the CSO. Like we don't have good doctors in Chicago to deal with his issue. He should have honored his commitment to the city but the CSO looks like a bunch of morons
barques95 1 year ago
Great words from this famous Maestro: ...more and more I less believe in what the conductors can do ... because this is a race what should be disappeared...
tpzvn 1 year ago
Brilliant Maestro Muti! Thank you for showing this rare footage!
jtrstrings 1 year ago
One conductor who gets it.
loudlong 1 year ago
Do you still have the entire copy of this?
turandotfan 1 year ago
A great guy, a great conductor. What he says is so true, but not everyone would have the courage to say it...
sphere82 1 year ago
1:22 !! I Love this man ! I guess he mentioned Karajan...HA HA HA !!!
sam0xin 1 year ago
Is there still a way to get a copy of this? This is fantastic! Thanks for any help you can lend.
svobodamatthew 1 year ago
JohnStubbs52...could I have also a complete copy? how much i need to pay?
Ssstinky 1 year ago
I want a copy too...
JustJoke89 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is wonderful. Could you please tell me where I could find the full video (I am in Australia)?
maestrasgw 1 year ago
This is wonderful. Could you please tell me where I could find the full video (I am in Australia)
maestrasgw 1 year ago
@maestrasgw
I also am in Australia and would love a copy of the full video.
MsBelles1 1 year ago
BRAVO!!!!
bachkwt 1 year ago
may I ask You to send this video to me ?
JustJoke89 1 year ago
Do you still have a copy?
salsadance999 1 year ago
Thank you. This is pure gold.
I do not have the score. And, can't understand the modulation he is discussing at 2:07 does anyone know the chords is discussing with the note C in common?
jpstenino 1 year ago
He says it in italian. C major to A flat major.
FabioGhibli 1 year ago
@FabioGhibli Thank you for the interpretation. I remember "discovering" that progression. I was about 10 years of age and drove everyone in the house mad by playing it over and over.
jpstenino 1 year ago
Bravo! Maestro!
malfada22 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Muti is right. He is irrelevant. The first moment when he shoud be helping the woodwinds with tempo, he runs his hand through his hair. Then, instead of concentrating on the woodwinds, he turns the page of his score and is late in giving the cue to the violins, who of course , having no conductor, are on auto pilot and don't breathe as a good conductor would remind them to. Then we get an oratorio from Muti as to why the orchestra can do it alone! But they didn't didn't they?
ConductingProfessor 2 years ago
So, ConductingProfessor, how did you choose your username? Your entry thoroughly disqualifies it.
lvb555 1 year ago
So, ConductingProfessor, how did you choose your username? Your entry thoroughly disqualifies it.
lvb555 1 year ago
I am a conductor, and you are 100-% correct. Muti has ruined opera singing, taking away the technical necessity of portamento (no, it's NOT a matter of "taste," it's a technical necessity!) and in this video blathers on about what is musically important without helping the orchestra s ingle bit. Bah! Egomaniac!
billyguns2 1 year ago
I'm a film director
verrrry intresting
verrrry jazzz
algowin 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
he looks like the guy from no country for old men.
sackbreath360 2 years ago
WONDERFUL!!!
jpstenino 2 years ago 3
According to a great finnish conductor and teacher Jorma Panula one of the most important things is not to disturb the orchestra! When it's going well, so let it flow.
He said also to us playing in the orchestra: dont mind this gesture, it's only for the audience.
50MusicMan 2 years ago 13
@50MusicMan Gesture only for the audience: it's a real stupid thing, sorry...
gaemp 1 year ago
@gaemp Hey man - humor?! That's what the grand old man has, would't hurt anyone...
50MusicMan 1 year ago
@50MusicMan Yes, this was also one of the preferred suggesting of Karajan; he used to say «if they know what to do and they do it alon, don't disturb!»
Matteo7419 9 months ago
Comment removed
ergoiamtoo 2 years ago
OMG For the first time I hear a person speaking english with an accent stronger then mine. I fell better!
MrLupo23 2 years ago 3
The second rate hot shot in Los Angeles should see this
dziady1 2 years ago 3
Can nobody upload the whole video of this rehearsal?
StefanGraz 2 years ago
Riccardo Muti is my cousin!
Kydako 2 years ago
@Kydako
doublealufwaffe 2 years ago
sorry "johnstubbs52",
if you know what is the title of the music played? thanks!!
anyway....Muti for president!!!
robertogrepazzo 2 years ago 2
Dvorak's Symphony No. 5, 1st movement
K491 2 years ago
hey, do you can send a copy to me????? Great Video!!!
Cassianoam 2 years ago
Johnstubbs25,
do u have d' complete copy of this work?
Manuel17jccj 2 years ago
yes i do.
if you want a copy, send me your address and i'll be glad to send it to you. the quality is bit low because it is a copy.
johnstubbs52 2 years ago
@johnstubbs52 please, I would like that either!
ehere do I send you my email?
maraxus83 1 year ago
@johnstubbs52
Could you possibly send me the copy of this work as well? Thank you so much!
gmunoz1028 1 year ago
@johnstubbs52
I just came by your video and i see that someone has asked you for a copy.
It's fabolous! I know I ask you this one year after but would you have a copy?
alexakaluigi214 1 year ago
@johnstubbs52
Hey, i'd like the copy myself, i've just discoverd Muti and i'm impressed, i want the full recording.
senectut 1 year ago
@johnstubbs52 Hi! can you send me the complete work? thank you!
klakitan 3 months ago
@johnstubbs52 can you send me a copy too?
telvidge92 3 months ago
Do you have the full version of this conducting lesson/rehearsal? I like Muti's style.
StefanGraz 2 years ago
i was given a bootleg copy. i can't find the original commercial recording. would you like a copy?
johnstubbs52 2 years ago
Would be great to have a copy of this. Could you help me?
StefanGraz 2 years ago
give me your address and i will send you a dvd.
johnstubbs52 2 years ago
@johnstubbs52 Could you send me full copy of this ?
JustJoke89 1 year ago
Thanks for that offer, but I think it would be easier to upload it here.
StefanGraz 2 years ago
Was this a full tape? If so, how could I go about procuring it?
Thanks
hitmanroy 2 years ago
give me your address and i'll send a copy.
johnstubbs52 2 years ago
One of the BEST!
urregoluis 2 years ago
Wow, when Muti wasn't a spoiled brat.
samuraitaliano77 2 years ago
Can you explain this comment? Does this have to do with the La Scala Controversy?
Will6721 2 years ago
I like this video very much. I think Riccardo Muti's personality and outlook have changed very much over the years.
glcolon 2 years ago
WOW !
)))))
JustJoke89 2 years ago
yes yes yes yes!!!!! Where did you find this!??!?!?
Will6721 3 years ago
sorry for the late reply.
a friend sent me a copy. i can't find any commercial versions of it.
johnstubbs52 3 years ago