Im sorry!, but there is no way the Japanese dub is better than the English dub. The reason is that all the characters sound like they are all from Japan, on the english version they all sound with the accent of the country each character is from story wise and thats the key difference. Mostly on any anime the Japanses dub is better than the English but not this time sir, including any anime from the 90's.
Hey, is there a version in this video with japanese voice with english subtitles? I really want to know what are they saying, while listening them speaking japanese.
These actors are wonderful, and while Hayter did try to sound too "cool" initially, realistically (and Kojima admitted this himself) that the characters would interact in English, and in many ways, it is actually superior. While Wolf sounds dying desperate and sad, her long-drawn accent in the English version, tired and weary, actually portrays this death with more poignancy. Akio Otsuka sounds cool, but Hayter seems more emotional.
I know what you mean man I think the reason why they don't make games like that anymore is because they got tired of watching all those cutscenes cause it feels like they are watching a movie lol.
Has anyone ever noticed that "beep" noise that is heard in the background during the cutscene? I thought it was a nice touch; it's like some beeping sound indicating her vital status or something, even though she is dying.
oh c'mon..if u watch japanese anime a lot u'll have no problem with their voices...its always sounds the same...their voices are standard japanese anime/videogame voices...even when they use different people..its still the same...
Japanese voice actors are indeed more dramatic, and they've always been. I actually prefered Snake's japanese voice actor do David Hayter, specially after MGS3.
In MGS3 and 4 both Big Boss and Old Snake look manlier, and not nearly as young as snake looks on MGS1. So I always thought the original japanese voice fits him perfectly.
Other than that, I have no problems with the English Voice Actors. Liquid's nailed it. It was top-notch. Just hearing him say "Brother!"..
@DemihumanGosu To be honest, Hayter did a bad job in MGS, he sounded too raspy with his "Batman voice" (the one in the Dark Knight) and trying to act tough. Japanese sounds more natural and flowed better. I do think Hayter did better in MGS2 and MGS3.
@ppshchik If anything, Hayter's Batman/Clint Eastwood voice was most subdued in MGS. It wasn't until later that he became too Clint Eastwood-like to be bareable, although MGS3 was the best I've seen from him.
@DemihumanGosu The japanese do an awesome job at voices and expressing emotions, especially in animes.
However personally I prefer the english Snake. David Hayter's voice defines Snake for me. The japanese Snake sounds like... I don't know, just like any "manly" hero, there's nothing unique about him for me :/
Ok. Otacon voice seems shitty to me. Snake sounds like an Anime Superhero... but Sniper Wolf sounds superb!! I'll download this ONLY for the Japanese audio. Sniper kinda turns me on with her voice XD
Meh, I can't choose which one I like better. I personally prefer the english one, but then again, I must say that I love the Japanese VA for Sniper Wolf...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm sorry but the JapaneseVoice acting in this kicks 10 shades of dog feces out of the American version. Most everybody in the American version(Including snake)sounds like they got a red wood shoved up their ass and rarely does anything they say affect me, however when I saw this I cried for the first time ever. It wasn't overly melodramatic like it is in the American version. I can go on all day on why anything dubbed over here sucks cat ass but just wanted to say that the Japan version is tits
it is. it is waaaay better. when i think of the character of solid snake from metal gear, and metal gear 2, i think of david hayters solid snake. the voice for the english version is so amazing. along with all the other characters, especially solid snake though.
what be because you don't really understand the Japanese :P I think they are kinda equally good, but Wolf's voice is better with the accent that Japanese can't really do. But they actors are more emotional in Japanese and that's what makes them equal to me.
LMFAO! This is what I hate about Metal Gear Solid series... After you defeat a boss, you have to listen to their life's stories... and they are always so damn sad!!!! Then you feel sorry for killing them!!! Damn you sniper wolf! Your scene is still touching even today!!!!!! T-T..... I love that background music too...
The difference between the English and Japanese version is interesting. The Japanese one is more realistic because Wolf sounds in more pain, but the English one is more moving because she sounds like she's peacefully slipping away.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
it do b listen 2 it several times over and snake iz a dumbass u are getting sniped and u wanna sit still really awesome fucking logic from u snake wel thats what u get from japanese game developers fukin dumb fuks
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
in this scene they r dumb fuks if u are gettin shot at by a sniper do u want to become a easy target by standing still for da snipa 2 get a clear shot IN DA OPEN/ dis scene still makes me laugh my ass off b
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Sorry to say this, although I love Japan. There's no depth in the voice acting it's all the same. Specially the female actors they all sound the same.
I disagree. Japanese female voice actress can sound really cute, seductive as hell, or plain angry. I like the male voices, too, because some of them soud like they'll beat the shit outta someone.
That's only in porn and manga that we hear those voices but then again that's just an expression anyone can do angry, cute or seductive, but to have depth and character is a different thing for example characters like the pain, joy, lady luck whatever her name is by hearing their voice you can tell what background they're from, what happened to them etc.
Do you know what make the voice acting of this version so great? It's because of the characters' mouths. Since they can't move their mouts, they have to "shake" something of their bodies or else, no one can guess which one of them is talking. And due to the fact that they can't open their mouths, the voice actors don't have to worry about the "lip sync". That's what makes it easier to speak normally.
i came up with that conclusion myself too. In MGS2 and MGS3, the VAs had a signal telling them when to start and stop talking. Did you know that in MGS4, the VAs are watching the motion capture sessions as they do the voice acting? Not to mention, they are also matching the lips to the voices in English as well. I think that it will look more realistic and flow better than MGS2 and 3
"Not to mention, they are also matching the lips to the voices in English as well."
They actually did that in MGS2 too, if you compare the US and Japanese versions you'll notice that the lip movement is very different in both versions. Even in MGS1 they adjusted the lip movement during codec dialogues.
I don't know if anyone of you watches anime and knows some of the more famous Japanese seiyuus, but I think that Sniper Wolf's voice actress sounds just like Koshimizu Ami (Mai Otome/Mai HiME etc.).
I see ... so the japanese version has excellent voice acting, too. Dont kill me for it, but I still prefer to english VA's better. Part of its familiarity with the language, which maks the nuances in the VAs performance comprehensible. And I'm a littl eupset 'cause I dont think they were able to get her accent at all ... but, y'know, this was still great. Sniper Wolf was SO my fave FOXHOUND member
It's said that Kojima himself prefers the English VO's of Metal Gear Solid because David Hayter (and probably the rest of the cast) do such a good job. I know he's not part of FOX HOUND but Otacon was always my favorite MGS character.
Actually "uru" doesn't mean wolf. "Uru" is "Wolf" spelled by Japanese. For example Liquid Snake is spelled in Japan "Rikiddo Suneku" and Solid Snake is "Soriddo Suneku".
Nah, you just mistook the word "urufu" for "uru", but there is no need to apologize because your explanation was actually correct. It was just a little mistake, nothing more. :)
Sure, it was more emotional, but my only grip is that she doesn't sound from middle-east anymore (well, how could you reproduce that kind of accent in japanese).
i mean this scene. japanese voice actors all sound too generic. snakes english voice is much cooler than his jpn voice. and wolf's ps1 performace was perfect.
...Maybe, but I like both! And the Dubbing in Japanese Match's the Lip-Sync! Which is what i'd like in the English Version, especially The Twin Snakes < which was rushed like a Bitch! Wasn't impressed with that tbh, Game Play Owned, but not that! Original was better for that... & everything else ofc!
He said he prefered them speaking english as that's the language they'd realistically speak. He never outright said that the actual voice acting is better though.
And he did say he was disappointed with MGS2's english voice acting in a japanese interview. Subsequentially he stopped releasing the english language versions in Japan after MGS2.
The Japanese version has better voice actors (chosen because of their voice acting) has emotion, personality and uniqueness for each character
While the american one doesnt have ANY, chose random people off the streets to read lines like a robot which makes the game dull, no anything no nothing sounds like shit, compare watching american ones and the Japanese one and you'll know the big difference
@LeonScottKennedySama The thing is, the Japanese seiyuu are of the Dragonball variety, most of them had roles in Dragonball. The English actors are of the Cartoon Network variety.
Dragonball had a level of pathos and emotional variety.
@MrLunitunz Banjo Ginga voiced souther hokuto no ken, Kaneto shiozawa voiced rei from hokuto no ken, koji totani voiced devilman and some other dragonball characters, also hokuto no ken and dragonball was both made from toei animation, you should watch hokuto no ken, banjo ginga was fucking awesome as souther.
Koji Totani was Jagi, as well as King lieutenant Club, Jackal's right hand man, Fox, and Shuran Rasho Han in Hokuto no Ken, and sadly, he's dead. In those Shin Kyuseishu Densetsu Hokuto no Ken movies made by TMS entertainment, Akio Ohtsuka (Solid Snake) replaced Banjo Ginga (Liquid Snake) as Souther. P.S, Koji Totani also voiced Young Ryuken in Hokuto no Ken.
@HannesHansen I tend to agree with Kojima if that's what he actually said... both versions are awesome, but the English one has a more realistic feel for obvious reasons...
yes snake stand crouch in the open.
EDDIEinWAR 3 weeks ago
Im sorry!, but there is no way the Japanese dub is better than the English dub. The reason is that all the characters sound like they are all from Japan, on the english version they all sound with the accent of the country each character is from story wise and thats the key difference. Mostly on any anime the Japanses dub is better than the English but not this time sir, including any anime from the 90's.
Hyan36 1 month ago
Hey, is there a version in this video with japanese voice with english subtitles? I really want to know what are they saying, while listening them speaking japanese.
Mpouketidias 5 months ago
Uhm...there is 'Metal Gear Solid: Integral' where you can change the subtitles.
filipeflower 5 months ago
Sniper wolf is better in the english version, Snake in this.
glassmuxxic 9 months ago
Why? Why can't they make a game like this anymore? I don't remember the last time a video game other than Metal Gear actually made me feel emotions!
narutokhinuyasha 1 year ago
The Japanese version is good but i still like the English one better
ESP3III 1 year ago 2
Akio Ohtsuka...He voiced his share of villians throughout his career...
vestoras 1 year ago
@vestoras Akio Ohtsuka also voiced Seth in Street Fighter IV
boredstudent 1 year ago
The english voices are a billion times better, the japanese voices in this game are just wayyyy over the top
Holykatzbob 1 year ago
These actors are wonderful, and while Hayter did try to sound too "cool" initially, realistically (and Kojima admitted this himself) that the characters would interact in English, and in many ways, it is actually superior. While Wolf sounds dying desperate and sad, her long-drawn accent in the English version, tired and weary, actually portrays this death with more poignancy. Akio Otsuka sounds cool, but Hayter seems more emotional.
DevilsArcadia777 1 year ago
Тяжёлая сцена...
GUYMFF 1 year ago
Everyone Otacon loves dies..thank God Snake isn't gay...but he's not better off being his friend lol.
kikook222 1 year ago
hands down, the best scene ever! especially with the theme "enclosure" playing.. i was shedding tears =*) it sounds so much better in japanese
khmaivietboi 1 year ago
Comment removed
khmaivietboi 1 year ago
Can you upload Meryl's death in Japanese as well? Kind of curious
ppshchik 1 year ago
wuta a good game ever mgs1
FAHDSAJER 1 year ago
@HannesHansen
My message was to the wrong guy, it was suppose to be @Allistar123
Hate the new youtube
LeonScottKennedySama 1 year ago
yea a whole new lvl of GENERIC.
eng mgs FTW
asdasdqweqwe2131 1 year ago
best game ever.
atech14 1 year ago
She sounds sexier here. Wolf and snake make a better couple.
JRock0085 1 year ago
The japanese Sniper Wolf voice acting girl is just so...
OMG so touching... so deep...i cried :(
oOoValkyrieoOo 1 year ago 6
What are you fighting for?
ego2d 2 years ago
in my opinion Akio Ōtsuka y davi hayter are two diferent snakes. both good but Akio Ōtsuka is a whole new level
alexrod830515 2 years ago
this is so much more badass where can i get a copy of mgs3 in japanese do i need an import chip as well
xraidedlok 2 years ago
ITS true that Mgs1 has the best story line ever.................but when mgs 4 came out it aties all the mgs games together MGS4 BABY
darkself 2 years ago
Eh, i prefer the american version. This one is alright.
TheSecretAgentBob 2 years ago
Jap voice acting so much better.
hakuga05 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahaha, stupid bitch. Nobody mess with Snake.
TheAnimalHater 2 years ago
maybe you are right.
baishihua 2 years ago
Why they dont make games like this anymore ...
MGS the best Game ever
Chupacabras84 2 years ago 28
I know what you mean man I think the reason why they don't make games like that anymore is because they got tired of watching all those cutscenes cause it feels like they are watching a movie lol.
PlanetXObserver 2 years ago
Otacon: Onegai! Suuneeku! Urufu!!
Wolf: Urusai!!!!!
hikarunkun 2 years ago 4
Has anyone ever noticed that "beep" noise that is heard in the background during the cutscene? I thought it was a nice touch; it's like some beeping sound indicating her vital status or something, even though she is dying.
dave55811 2 years ago 4
yeah HannesHansen
you are right!
YASUCITY 2 years ago 2
even in japanese this scene makes me cry
sirwinsalot 2 years ago 5
wolf is a kurd=P? i didnt know that..XD and ive played trough this game in both english and japanese at least 10 timesXD
iFukuyama 2 years ago
I think she makes it clear in this scene.
EscanorTheBrave 2 years ago 4
thats what i commented on..=P
iFukuyama 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
yeah, i watched many animes, why their voice sounds all the same
baishihua 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh c'mon..if u watch japanese anime a lot u'll have no problem with their voices...its always sounds the same...their voices are standard japanese anime/videogame voices...even when they use different people..its still the same...
nomankun100 2 years ago
Either you have only watched one anime, or you're just plain stupid. I've heard a lot of anime voices, and none of them sound alike.
totoofze47 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
remake is better!!!!!!!!!!!!
tanos1998 2 years ago
para mi la le mejor saga de juego es lejos MGS
casuela1991 2 years ago
Japanese voice actors are indeed more dramatic, and they've always been. I actually prefered Snake's japanese voice actor do David Hayter, specially after MGS3.
In MGS3 and 4 both Big Boss and Old Snake look manlier, and not nearly as young as snake looks on MGS1. So I always thought the original japanese voice fits him perfectly.
Other than that, I have no problems with the English Voice Actors. Liquid's nailed it. It was top-notch. Just hearing him say "Brother!"..
DemihumanGosu 2 years ago 29
@DemihumanGosu Personally I prefer Cam Clarke over Banjo Ginga. Cam has that British accent going , Banjo's is just a deep voice.
MrLunitunz 1 year ago
@DemihumanGosu To be honest, Hayter did a bad job in MGS, he sounded too raspy with his "Batman voice" (the one in the Dark Knight) and trying to act tough. Japanese sounds more natural and flowed better. I do think Hayter did better in MGS2 and MGS3.
ppshchik 1 year ago
@ppshchik If anything, Hayter's Batman/Clint Eastwood voice was most subdued in MGS. It wasn't until later that he became too Clint Eastwood-like to be bareable, although MGS3 was the best I've seen from him.
MrLunitunz 1 year ago
@DemihumanGosu The japanese do an awesome job at voices and expressing emotions, especially in animes.
However personally I prefer the english Snake. David Hayter's voice defines Snake for me. The japanese Snake sounds like... I don't know, just like any "manly" hero, there's nothing unique about him for me :/
Panikdemet 6 months ago
xd
ggggg
driveseegta10 2 years ago
Snake- It was ok, but it's to deep @_@
Otacon- It's ok.
Sniper Wolf- That voice actor was amazing, you could tell that she was in real pain.
WolfLink95 2 years ago 3
I love sniper wolf
anna1644 2 years ago
Ok. Otacon voice seems shitty to me. Snake sounds like an Anime Superhero... but Sniper Wolf sounds superb!! I'll download this ONLY for the Japanese audio. Sniper kinda turns me on with her voice XD
xtairakunx 2 years ago 2
Meh, I can't choose which one I like better. I personally prefer the english one, but then again, I must say that I love the Japanese VA for Sniper Wolf...
greenlantern72 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but the JapaneseVoice acting in this kicks 10 shades of dog feces out of the American version. Most everybody in the American version(Including snake)sounds like they got a red wood shoved up their ass and rarely does anything they say affect me, however when I saw this I cried for the first time ever. It wasn't overly melodramatic like it is in the American version. I can go on all day on why anything dubbed over here sucks cat ass but just wanted to say that the Japan version is tits
westernestates 3 years ago
well Hideo Kojima prefers the American version but hey your the expert so you must be right :D
Allistar123 3 years ago
Not exactly, he prefers them speaking in english, because they would of course speak english if this was real.
But he doesn't actually prefer the english voice acting in terms of quality.
HannesHansen 3 years ago
Well, I perfectly agree with that :P
aladore384 2 years ago
@HannesHansen In fact he did a little poem thing on his website describing how much he loved Seiyuu, i.e. Japanese voice actors.
MrLunitunz 1 year ago
yep
xraidedlok 3 years ago 2
u wouldnt have the balls, nychpyno21!! lol oj
chrisvalez 3 years ago
i feel the english version is way better....but that's just me
200dogz 3 years ago
it is. it is waaaay better. when i think of the character of solid snake from metal gear, and metal gear 2, i think of david hayters solid snake. the voice for the english version is so amazing. along with all the other characters, especially solid snake though.
cannabisisgood420 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its not english it is amerikan
jaik0wn 3 years ago
what be because you don't really understand the Japanese :P I think they are kinda equally good, but Wolf's voice is better with the accent that Japanese can't really do. But they actors are more emotional in Japanese and that's what makes them equal to me.
Spitenike 3 years ago
nice!!
yyfrz 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"Snake? ..do you believe that... love can bloom on the battle field?"
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why I hate Otocan.
10truefreak01 3 years ago
if i was here i knock snakes head off his shoulders with that sniper
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
LMFAO! This is what I hate about Metal Gear Solid series... After you defeat a boss, you have to listen to their life's stories... and they are always so damn sad!!!! Then you feel sorry for killing them!!! Damn you sniper wolf! Your scene is still touching even today!!!!!! T-T..... I love that background music too...
boredguy 3 years ago 7
The difference between the English and Japanese version is interesting. The Japanese one is more realistic because Wolf sounds in more pain, but the English one is more moving because she sounds like she's peacefully slipping away.
drazen86 3 years ago 8
ソリッドカッコいい!!!
RACINGUYA 3 years ago 2
-7 im da shit bitch check da senses b
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
The japanese voice actress for Wolf did a great job :)
Peacekeeper88 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
japan MGS sounds gay if u dont agree and you "are" used to the english version then Fuck you
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
Lol, I'm used to the english version (having only played that one) but I like listening to the japanese voices. You're just dumb.
Gutted94 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they sound gay japanese only sounds good in DOA 4 da xbox
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
Why do you think they are attracted to people of the same sex just because of their voices?
Gutted94 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wat da fuk u iz talkin bout b?
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
You say it sounds "gay"
Gutted94 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it do b listen 2 it several times over and snake iz a dumbass u are getting sniped and u wanna sit still really awesome fucking logic from u snake wel thats what u get from japanese game developers fukin dumb fuks
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
Dude, do you like the game or not?
Gutted94 3 years ago
i played it 55 times on my PSX
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
55?! And now you're calling the developers dumbfucks?
Gutted94 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
in this scene they r dumb fuks if u are gettin shot at by a sniper do u want to become a easy target by standing still for da snipa 2 get a clear shot IN DA OPEN/ dis scene still makes me laugh my ass off b
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
Time freezes when you use the codec, honestly
Gutted94 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dats wat japanese people think exactly as they freeze when they are about to get da stank on da old hang low u feel me son 1
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
You shouldn't hate the japanese so much for nothing
Gutted94 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
geah i should since a japanese nigga fuked my order up in a chinese restaurant
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shouldn't it have been a chinese "nigga"?
Gutted94 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
a Japanese mo-fo was workin in a chinese place WTF b?
nYcHypno21 3 years ago
Its just like movies too. "They have to talk before a fight" ... hahaha. Maybe Sniper wolf wanted a fair fight? hahahaha
boredguy 3 years ago
point is kurd is not wolf.who made that mistake?hideo?
brandonklex 3 years ago
You can't assume that's a mistake until you obtain full-confirmation of it. Contact Hideo or Konami staff.
filipeflower 3 years ago
However the word kurt in Turkish means wolf.
978kks 3 years ago 2
Snake is kind to those who he kills cause he really didn't want to do the mission in the first place, he was forced only
JPTorres26 3 years ago
the ONLY thing i dont like about this scene is that otacon doesn't kick snakes ass for killing wolf
chaz84720 3 years ago
Hal Emmerich is not that kind of person, you know. Even Hal himself said:
-"I told you before. I don't wanna hurt anyone."
filipeflower 3 years ago
but still people do crazy stuff when they are in love
chaz84720 3 years ago
You're just beeing stereotypical. Don't go that far.
filipeflower 3 years ago
well im not a fighter but if someone came in and killed my girl i would kill him right back
chaz84720 3 years ago
But she tried to kill Snake too. What was he supposed to do then?
HannesHansen 3 years ago
he could have stallyed her by codec
chaz84720 3 years ago
How?
filipeflower 3 years ago
i still play metal gear solid 1
Sailorchunli17 3 years ago
oh dear, i got shot... i'l just kneel down in the same location and make a codec call... lol not the same without david hayter
subbb85 3 years ago 5
david hayter aint shit to this one
xraidedlok 3 years ago
Another thing I want to say.....This particular cutscene is so much better than the re-make version for the GC...the song alone makes it so powerful.
Schwaby69 3 years ago 7
Otacon sounds more like a man in Japanese lol....
Schwaby69 3 years ago 7
yes
xraidedlok 3 years ago
i think japanese voices are better because in the us they make the men's voices too high pitched and women's voices too low
trogdorkilah 3 years ago
heh xept snake's
dudee789 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sorry to say this, although I love Japan. There's no depth in the voice acting it's all the same. Specially the female actors they all sound the same.
swiv2d 3 years ago
Very true.
pokoyg 3 years ago
I disagree. Japanese female voice actress can sound really cute, seductive as hell, or plain angry. I like the male voices, too, because some of them soud like they'll beat the shit outta someone.
Loader2K1 3 years ago 8
That's only in porn and manga that we hear those voices but then again that's just an expression anyone can do angry, cute or seductive, but to have depth and character is a different thing for example characters like the pain, joy, lady luck whatever her name is by hearing their voice you can tell what background they're from, what happened to them etc.
swiv2d 3 years ago
japanese voices in mgs for life!!!
mgs4 jap. version --> coming at home to me --> confirmed!! ^ .^
first the german and after i rule it, mgs4 jap. the next >_>
snaaaaakkee!! >=D
DonMasakoni 4 years ago
I like both the Japanese and English versions.
yuyuzja 4 years ago 10
me to
Simpan86 4 years ago 5
me to! xD
Zack989889898989 4 years ago
Is it just me or does Snake have no eyes?
Schattenfaust2 4 years ago
His eyes are too dark to be seen.
filipeflower 4 years ago 3
Heh, fair enough. I was gonna blame it on the PSX's graphics, myself. Eh, still funny to see him looking like he's got no eyes.
Schattenfaust2 4 years ago 2
Do you know what make the voice acting of this version so great? It's because of the characters' mouths. Since they can't move their mouts, they have to "shake" something of their bodies or else, no one can guess which one of them is talking. And due to the fact that they can't open their mouths, the voice actors don't have to worry about the "lip sync". That's what makes it easier to speak normally.
filipeflower 4 years ago 3
Yep. I guess so.
Schattenfaust2 4 years ago
i came up with that conclusion myself too. In MGS2 and MGS3, the VAs had a signal telling them when to start and stop talking. Did you know that in MGS4, the VAs are watching the motion capture sessions as they do the voice acting? Not to mention, they are also matching the lips to the voices in English as well. I think that it will look more realistic and flow better than MGS2 and 3
temp5056 4 years ago 2
"Not to mention, they are also matching the lips to the voices in English as well."
They actually did that in MGS2 too, if you compare the US and Japanese versions you'll notice that the lip movement is very different in both versions. Even in MGS1 they adjusted the lip movement during codec dialogues.
They didn't do it in MGS3 though.
HannesHansen 3 years ago
I don't know if anyone of you watches anime and knows some of the more famous Japanese seiyuus, but I think that Sniper Wolf's voice actress sounds just like Koshimizu Ami (Mai Otome/Mai HiME etc.).
AquariusX2 4 years ago
Omg, this scene is so sad! I had to cry when I first saw it, but the Japanese versions beats the English one, totally ;_;.
DreamingBookCastles 4 years ago
I love Wolf's voice in the Japanese version. She sounds more...feminine.
CelesteDealcroix 4 years ago 2
Yup. You're right. Her voice is really good. But I like her english voice too, her german voice is bad.
0SniperWolf0 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is this chinese or japanese. coz the chinese dont talk like this. This sounds better
cloud360 4 years ago
it´s japanese
everyhobby 4 years ago
I see ... so the japanese version has excellent voice acting, too. Dont kill me for it, but I still prefer to english VA's better. Part of its familiarity with the language, which maks the nuances in the VAs performance comprehensible. And I'm a littl eupset 'cause I dont think they were able to get her accent at all ... but, y'know, this was still great. Sniper Wolf was SO my fave FOXHOUND member
KealymLW 4 years ago 6
It's said that Kojima himself prefers the English VO's of Metal Gear Solid because David Hayter (and probably the rest of the cast) do such a good job. I know he's not part of FOX HOUND but Otacon was always my favorite MGS character.
ZekeBarzahd 4 years ago 5
i disagree,i think the original voices are better(snake sounds much deeper),but i respect your opinion
everyhobby 4 years ago 4
Actually "uru" doesn't mean wolf. "Uru" is "Wolf" spelled by Japanese. For example Liquid Snake is spelled in Japan "Rikiddo Suneku" and Solid Snake is "Soriddo Suneku".
Sounds strange, huh?
(Of course, my brothers, I might be wrong.)
TosiPerkele 4 years ago
Uhm, not exactly.
Originally, "wolf" is "ookami" in Japanese and the pronunciation of the English word "wolf" in Japanese is "urufu".
But I don't know the Japanese pronunciation of "sniper". It may be "sunaipa", but I'm not sure.
AquariusX2 4 years ago
Sorry for my English. Acually I meant exatly what you said. I explained it wrong. Sorry.
TosiPerkele 4 years ago
Nah, you just mistook the word "urufu" for "uru", but there is no need to apologize because your explanation was actually correct. It was just a little mistake, nothing more. :)
AquariusX2 4 years ago
uru is Japanese for wolf, right?
SniperNightOwl 4 years ago
An incredible shivering scene, Metal Gear Solid is one of Psx best game, and one of best video game ever created.
shineph 4 years ago
what the heck does Snake say at :50? He sounds really pissed off.
summerguy03 4 years ago 2
Wow, Japanese Dub is really good! Love the emotion.
Heero14 4 years ago 7
better than the english version(which isn´t bad,either)
everyhobby 4 years ago 2
I'm a Kurd too :P
Curdo1985 4 years ago
well
the best cut scene ever is it's equivalent in mgs2, death of Emma Emmerich
MunstaCookie 4 years ago
It's just my opinion, but I think especially Sniper Wolfs japanese voice is far better and more emotional in this scene.
As for the lip-sync. They did match up the codec lip-sync to the englisch voice acting in the PSX version.
HannesHansen 4 years ago
Sure, it was more emotional, but my only grip is that she doesn't sound from middle-east anymore (well, how could you reproduce that kind of accent in japanese).
POLE7645 4 years ago
To me, Sniper Wolf sounds Russian, even though she is suppose to be Kurdish.
jooshiscrazy 2 years ago
not as well done as the english version
tehdud 4 years ago
The Japanese Version looks way better for Codec Lip-Sync! The Twin Snakes was the Worst for that! (In English!)
MetalGearRider 4 years ago 2
i mean this scene. japanese voice actors all sound too generic. snakes english voice is much cooler than his jpn voice. and wolf's ps1 performace was perfect.
tehdud 4 years ago
...Maybe, but I like both! And the Dubbing in Japanese Match's the Lip-Sync! Which is what i'd like in the English Version, especially The Twin Snakes < which was rushed like a Bitch! Wasn't impressed with that tbh, Game Play Owned, but not that! Original was better for that... & everything else ofc!
MetalGearRider 4 years ago
That's because the Japanese version is the original version. The English version is a dub, so it's not going to be perfect.
jooshiscrazy 2 years ago
it's better even kojima said the american version is better.
Allistar123 2 years ago 4
He said he prefered them speaking english as that's the language they'd realistically speak. He never outright said that the actual voice acting is better though.
And he did say he was disappointed with MGS2's english voice acting in a japanese interview. Subsequentially he stopped releasing the english language versions in Japan after MGS2.
HannesHansen 2 years ago 2
Doesn't the Japanese version of MGS3: Subsistence have English voice acting?
jooshiscrazy 2 years ago
Nope, MGS2: Substance was the last english language release in Japan.
HannesHansen 2 years ago
@HannesHansen
The Japanese version has better voice actors (chosen because of their voice acting) has emotion, personality and uniqueness for each character
While the american one doesnt have ANY, chose random people off the streets to read lines like a robot which makes the game dull, no anything no nothing sounds like shit, compare watching american ones and the Japanese one and you'll know the big difference
LeonScottKennedySama 1 year ago
@LeonScottKennedySama The thing is, the Japanese seiyuu are of the Dragonball variety, most of them had roles in Dragonball. The English actors are of the Cartoon Network variety.
Dragonball had a level of pathos and emotional variety.
Cartoon Network productions are just comedies.
Thus the difference in quality.
MrLunitunz 1 year ago
@MrLunitunz
I hope you are joking, "Japanese Seiyuu are DBZ variety?"
When did this happen? DBZ is just ONE anime, theres hundreds of different seiyuu and they are handpicked by their unique voices.
English actors are probably chosen by getting picked off from the street
LeonScottKennedySama 1 year ago
@LeonScottKennedySama I didn't mean in general. I meant the MGS Seiyuu.
Hiromi Tsuru (Naomi) was Bulma
Takeshi Aono (Campbell) was Picollo Sr/Kami
Kaneto Shiozawa had a role
Koji Totani had a role
Banjo Ginga probably had a role.
Most of them had Dragonball parts and I don't think it's purely coincidental.
MrLunitunz 1 year ago
@MrLunitunz Banjo Ginga voiced souther hokuto no ken, Kaneto shiozawa voiced rei from hokuto no ken, koji totani voiced devilman and some other dragonball characters, also hokuto no ken and dragonball was both made from toei animation, you should watch hokuto no ken, banjo ginga was fucking awesome as souther.
pocketmonsterfreak 1 year ago
Koji Totani was Jagi, as well as King lieutenant Club, Jackal's right hand man, Fox, and Shuran Rasho Han in Hokuto no Ken, and sadly, he's dead. In those Shin Kyuseishu Densetsu Hokuto no Ken movies made by TMS entertainment, Akio Ohtsuka (Solid Snake) replaced Banjo Ginga (Liquid Snake) as Souther. P.S, Koji Totani also voiced Young Ryuken in Hokuto no Ken.
AJ15ist 10 months ago
@HannesHansen Well I would've like to listen in Japanese.
ElricSowrd 1 year ago
@HannesHansen I tend to agree with Kojima if that's what he actually said... both versions are awesome, but the English one has a more realistic feel for obvious reasons...
satori137 1 year ago 2
Die beste stelle im ganzen spiel, der tot von sniper wolf war wirklich herzzerreißend
santocarme 4 years ago
Ich würd sogar sagen, die beste Stelle der gesamten MGS Reihe.*g*
HannesHansen 4 years ago
Great. Do you plan to upload more Japanese Metal Gear Solid cutscenes (or boss fights)?
POLE7645 4 years ago
Of course, but I'm doing a little break right now, there were lot of sound problems during recording, so it was quite stressfull, to record the vids.
But I'm definitly going to upload more, the best cutscenes from the 2nd disc.
HannesHansen 4 years ago
thanx for uploading this---hideo kojima is the best
kanedaking 4 years ago