Good song for bringout out the stupidity of American liberals. A flaming left wing liberal like Joan Baez singing a ballad about a time in history that makes most flaming left wing liberals start whining and screaming "racism". So, one minute they hum to this tune and the next minute they want to haul down the Confederate flag. The hypocrasy of the American left knows no boundries.
I have Woodstock on DVD, and I understand she has a child my age(41 years old). I wonder if she sang to her kids like this. If so,they would be fast asleep when she got through. Nice job, Joan.
Beautiful Version of this song. Nice song to commemorate the 150th anniversary of the Civil War here in Charleston, SC this week (April 12, 1861 was the firing of Fort Sumter and the beginning of the war)
Well you are partially correct but remember a lot of Union soldiers died as well and all because the rich old men in the northeast and New England were angry because they thought the rich old men in the south were going to make more money.
@ElMessiah Slavery is horrible. But back then "negroes" were happy on the plantations. Look at the inner cities now. Violence, prostitution, rampant incest, gangs, drug addiction, broken homes, and endless bullshit promises from Rev. Jackson, Sharpton, and Obama types. You tell me what is worse. Freedom is dangerous, unless you know how to use it.
These lyrics get tweaked quite a bit.Till so much cavalry came, is o.k. for an ad-lib but Stonewalls cavalry.I read Stonewall Jackson was full of peculiarities,lets hope that tearing up his own sides RR tracks wasn't one of them,then again he was killed by friendly fire.
Yea, she finally got General Stoneman of the Union Army in the lyrics right. How odd that this song was written by a Canadian (Robbie Robertson of THE BAND)
NO YOU ARE NOT A "WORKING MAN" you "work the land". Jesus, of all the lyrical errors she makes in the song, this one irritates me the most. Working the land describes a common Southerner of the time, a working man could be anyone in the big cities in the North.
its nice she sang this about the south. sad thing is that probably half the south back then and even today, never even heard of Joan Baez or even The Beatles! to much beer and to little education down there. damn shame.
And most of them know the lyrics to this song, unlike Baez. It just irritates me that she cared so little about the lyrics that she never even bothered to look them up before she recorded the song. It was just something she said she heard on the radio and thought it sounded cool. The meaning of the song was never interesting to her.
I didn't know that. Figures. Liberals always assume since they are defacto moraly superior to everyone else, they have license to borrow and rob from whomever they please.
who are you refering,,,this song was written by Robbie Robertson ,he is liberal,originally Bob Dylans band in the 60s,the song was origanally sung by Levon Helm the drummer in Robbys band,it is a respect for all north and south song
hEY VINEGAROON 1, HERE IS WHERE STONEMAN'S CAVALRY WAS in 1865:March 20, 1865 General George Stoneman leads a cavalry force of 4000 Union soldiers from Jonesborough, in east Tennesee, toward North Carolina. Stoneman's raid, which is designed in part to destroy enemy transport lines, is also intended to aid Sherman's campaign.
March 29, 1865 Eastern Theater, Appomattox Campaign,
Just speaking from some recent interviews I've seen of her, she seems like a bitter old woman now. I can't really blame her though, the way society has done a complete 180 since she was in the spotlight.
Search for "Joan Baez Sunday morning" on youtube and you'll see that she really isn't bitter at all. BTW calling a woman a "bitch" is simply misogynistic.
she says "so much cavelry" she says that she wrote the words down from hearing the Band. Also she says virgil is a Working man, when the original says he will work the land...that rather changes the song. still its a good song sung by a good singer . Deo Vindice
These videos are puzzling to me because I have a version of this song where she doesn't make these changes. She sings "Stonewall" -- in fact it is word for word the same as the Band's version. Why does she change the lyrics in these videos?
if you read some history of the band, Robbie Robertson said she sang the song without any original lyrics from the band. She picked up the chords and put the lyrics to them as she thought she had heard them. Still like the song, although I prefer Levon singing the song.
why is it that she changes the lyrics? It is to the point that they don't even make sense now. I took the train to Richmond that fell? How about you keep the original lyrics of, "may the tenth, richmond had fell?" Afterall it was how the song was written, and is historically accurate.
the voice is pure, from the heart and understanding the words. richmond, va in the early 1970's still disliked yankies. i a yankee was there january 1970. most folks understood the civel war was over but many wanted something else.
It's been over 30 years and She can sing any lyrics she wants. Her lyrics are an improvement and I am sure the Band never refused any royalty checks. She gave them their ONLY top ten hit. Nice soulful version here though, huh?
one lyric change isn't even caught by most listeners. The blood beneath is better than the mud beneath. Relax and give props to the pathos and perfect flow she brings to the song.
she also says "someone's calvary" not stoneman's, and completely misses winter of 65, it causes the song to loose meaning, its meant to be a story if you just discard the facts it could be about anything.
Ah yes I checked it and you're right. I read on Wiki that she didn't even know the lyrics when she recorded it, she just sung what she thought she heard lol.
@Dogstar333 of course they weren't defeated, in their minds. But of course they took revenge on the innocent black population for more than a hundred years by passing very racist, segregationist and discriminatory laws (jim crow). As long as your people were and still able to make black people suffer they'd still believe that they weren't defeated. Thank God for Abe Lincoln and Martin Luther King Jr.
@KChery As is they were treated 'so well' in the North the last 100 years... at least tell the whole story. Plenty of Slavery existed in the North. Up until the late 1830's, only one place in the U.S. sold more slaves than Charleston---- New York City.
@KChery As if they were treated 'so well' in the North the last 100 years... at least tell the whole story. Plenty of Slavery existed in the North. Up until the late 1830's, only one place in the U.S. sold more slaves than Charleston---- New York City.
incredible insight, messiah. history repeats itself like a bad fart. war is never about selfdefense. it is about a handfull of leaders, who lied to get elected and then revealed their true colors to accomplish their own selfish pursuits, at the expense of a mass of misdirected youth they call - g.i.'s
trapping black people in an inescapable cycle of slavery? you're claiming that 'welfare' is the reason that people are poor? "do some research".....hmmmmm. i would say that you need to take your own advice. socialism has ..very little to do with welfare. one can have welfare capitalism, but it's still capitalism. socialism is the public ownership of the means of production. oy ve..
I was refering to the modern white supremacist view of adopting the old Confederacy songs and symbols for political propaganda purposes. The songs and flags historically have had little to do with those things both the far Right and Far left alike have claimed they represent.
Nice, but I am surprised she is singing that song. She is such a liberal progresive spokes person that I did not think that she could sing a song symbolic of old Confederacy (slavery and conservative values).
this song has nothing to do with slavery. conservative values have nothing to do with this song, either. There is a lot more to the fall of the old south than slavery and what you call "conservatve" values, and that is why this song has been covered by Baez, Johnny Cash, The Black Crowes, Vendetta Red, Bruce Hornsby, Jerry Garcia, The Decemberists. It is a song about heritage. get your stereotypical head out of the gutter.
Slavery is not a conservative value. However traping black people in a neverending, unexscapable cycle of socialist slavery through welfare appers to be a liberal value.
Do some research, nobody who died in the civil war owned a slave.
Any time you are ready Joan , there's a spot in my bed just for you.....JUST BRILLIANT
cootesmuz 2 weeks ago
What?? A little louder....Oh Ok SHHHHHhhhhh...... Ill Sing Along softly....
DJKRAYZMIKE 3 months ago
Good song for bringout out the stupidity of American liberals. A flaming left wing liberal like Joan Baez singing a ballad about a time in history that makes most flaming left wing liberals start whining and screaming "racism". So, one minute they hum to this tune and the next minute they want to haul down the Confederate flag. The hypocrasy of the American left knows no boundries.
40AcreMule 6 months ago
I have Woodstock on DVD, and I understand she has a child my age(41 years old). I wonder if she sang to her kids like this. If so,they would be fast asleep when she got through. Nice job, Joan.
kja427 7 months ago
Beautiful Version of this song. Nice song to commemorate the 150th anniversary of the Civil War here in Charleston, SC this week (April 12, 1861 was the firing of Fort Sumter and the beginning of the war)
Ladysensei 9 months ago
Wonderful artist, lovely song and excellent video quality.
SUNNYCAS 1 year ago
I think the Richie Havens solo version of this great song has a unique straight-up quality that makes for a wonderful result... I love it!
SpartacusDog1 1 year ago
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G !
Bojocatkite 1 year ago
@ElMessiah
Well you are partially correct but remember a lot of Union soldiers died as well and all because the rich old men in the northeast and New England were angry because they thought the rich old men in the south were going to make more money.
thebear1050 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ElMessiah Slavery is horrible. But back then "negroes" were happy on the plantations. Look at the inner cities now. Violence, prostitution, rampant incest, gangs, drug addiction, broken homes, and endless bullshit promises from Rev. Jackson, Sharpton, and Obama types. You tell me what is worse. Freedom is dangerous, unless you know how to use it.
rockyracune 1 year ago
These lyrics get tweaked quite a bit.Till so much cavalry came, is o.k. for an ad-lib but Stonewalls cavalry.I read Stonewall Jackson was full of peculiarities,lets hope that tearing up his own sides RR tracks wasn't one of them,then again he was killed by friendly fire.
koropal 1 year ago
Yea, she finally got General Stoneman of the Union Army in the lyrics right. How odd that this song was written by a Canadian (Robbie Robertson of THE BAND)
layton59 1 year ago
Only took her a couple decades to figure out its "Stoneman's" and not "Stonewall's" cavalry.
rr5n 2 years ago
Good point.
sartainja 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Awful. She's put it through the wash and rung all the life out of it.
MiataBRG 2 years ago
nope Joan, you didn't cut it on this one!! Sorry!
Garo48 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can Liberals PLEASE learn how to dress? This Southern Democrat Joan Baez looks like the typical Liberal. Gray hair and horrible dresser!
spartanofdelphi 2 years ago
Beautiful.
I love this song generally but Baez' cover is my favourite version of it.
x
Arbeeroro 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
f**k this
camdan492 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this broad sucks. totally fucked this song up royally. she shoulda never touched it.. the black crowes and johnny cash did the best covers of this.
sl26t 2 years ago
"Southron musicians?" Joan's got a great voice, or did have in her prime. Wish I could play guitar as well as she.
Myrtle791 2 years ago
when was this?
she's awesome!!
pandabaerchie 2 years ago 3
NO YOU ARE NOT A "WORKING MAN" you "work the land". Jesus, of all the lyrical errors she makes in the song, this one irritates me the most. Working the land describes a common Southerner of the time, a working man could be anyone in the big cities in the North.
RobertGary1 2 years ago
its nice she sang this about the south. sad thing is that probably half the south back then and even today, never even heard of Joan Baez or even The Beatles! to much beer and to little education down there. damn shame.
acerb45666555 2 years ago
I'm sure there are many excellent Southron musicians that you've never heard of. Asshole.
kwazi6 2 years ago
And most of them know the lyrics to this song, unlike Baez. It just irritates me that she cared so little about the lyrics that she never even bothered to look them up before she recorded the song. It was just something she said she heard on the radio and thought it sounded cool. The meaning of the song was never interesting to her.
RobertGary1 2 years ago
I didn't know that. Figures. Liberals always assume since they are defacto moraly superior to everyone else, they have license to borrow and rob from whomever they please.
kwazi6 2 years ago
who are you refering,,,this song was written by Robbie Robertson ,he is liberal,originally Bob Dylans band in the 60s,the song was origanally sung by Levon Helm the drummer in Robbys band,it is a respect for all north and south song
vaughnsalem 2 years ago 2
Let me alter my comment then. Liberals "usually"...
kwazi6 2 years ago
sofisticação !!!! muito linda.......
matuesg1 2 years ago
absolutely beautiful.
LCdunzo 2 years ago
hEY VINEGAROON 1, HERE IS WHERE STONEMAN'S CAVALRY WAS in 1865:March 20, 1865 General George Stoneman leads a cavalry force of 4000 Union soldiers from Jonesborough, in east Tennesee, toward North Carolina. Stoneman's raid, which is designed in part to destroy enemy transport lines, is also intended to aid Sherman's campaign.
March 29, 1865 Eastern Theater, Appomattox Campaign,
cwcav3tn 2 years ago
nice song
jakeyj93 3 years ago
she really over-sang this and seems very mellow-dramatic
kajes5 3 years ago
Danville is in Virginia, but Stoneman's cavalry was raiding in Georgia in 1865, right?
vinegaroon1 3 years ago
A voz dela ainda que não continue igual, continua boa, muito bonita.
Sandara29 3 years ago
Just speaking from some recent interviews I've seen of her, she seems like a bitter old woman now. I can't really blame her though, the way society has done a complete 180 since she was in the spotlight.
timlearybedead 3 years ago
i noticed that too. still u cant deny that amazing voice
shemalegazebo 2 years ago
Search for "Joan Baez Sunday morning" on youtube and you'll see that she really isn't bitter at all. BTW calling a woman a "bitch" is simply misogynistic.
pamina28 2 years ago
I love you
Mehdihmili 3 years ago
she says "so much cavelry" she says that she wrote the words down from hearing the Band. Also she says virgil is a Working man, when the original says he will work the land...that rather changes the song. still its a good song sung by a good singer . Deo Vindice
Mickey70114 3 years ago
Is Baez a Southerner?
GaGirlie777 3 years ago
This is a really quiet video.
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago 14
@54spiritedwill54 LMAO..but your right.
deltabtry 1 year ago
What the heck did I type? I meant stoneman not stonewall. obviously stonewall fought for the confederates!
vanauker2 3 years ago
These videos are puzzling to me because I have a version of this song where she doesn't make these changes. She sings "Stonewall" -- in fact it is word for word the same as the Band's version. Why does she change the lyrics in these videos?
vanauker2 3 years ago
Average
CrystalCanyons 3 years ago
if you read some history of the band, Robbie Robertson said she sang the song without any original lyrics from the band. She picked up the chords and put the lyrics to them as she thought she had heard them. Still like the song, although I prefer Levon singing the song.
KackyKay 3 years ago
why is it that she changes the lyrics? It is to the point that they don't even make sense now. I took the train to Richmond that fell? How about you keep the original lyrics of, "may the tenth, richmond had fell?" Afterall it was how the song was written, and is historically accurate.
randyfloyd07 3 years ago
Long live Dixie
Deo Vindice
stl6281z 3 years ago
Joan Baez forever!
txcail 3 years ago
Good cover. I wish she had a whole damn orchestra with her though
Aurileus5 3 years ago
a true star, Joan Baes.
the voice is pure, from the heart and understanding the words. richmond, va in the early 1970's still disliked yankies. i a yankee was there january 1970. most folks understood the civel war was over but many wanted something else.
wonder if feelings have changed much?
jim28518 3 years ago
It's amazing she was able to find a guitarist more affected than Robbie Robertson.
And with a worse voice!
tabber87 3 years ago
zing!
andrewcasarsa 3 years ago
you're a dick.
achioino 3 years ago
is she still a hippie because now she just looks like my 7th grade teacher.
StevenGA1011 3 years ago
HORRIBLE!
doddledont 3 years ago
After 20 years go by still singing the wrong lyrics - I don't get it!
Exnay777 3 years ago
It's been over 30 years and She can sing any lyrics she wants. Her lyrics are an improvement and I am sure the Band never refused any royalty checks. She gave them their ONLY top ten hit. Nice soulful version here though, huh?
taddyd1 3 years ago
rofl her lyrics are innacurate historically so the song loses all meaning
rikhurley 3 years ago
one lyric change isn't even caught by most listeners. The blood beneath is better than the mud beneath. Relax and give props to the pathos and perfect flow she brings to the song.
taddyd1 3 years ago
she also says "someone's calvary" not stoneman's, and completely misses winter of 65, it causes the song to loose meaning, its meant to be a story if you just discard the facts it could be about anything.
rikhurley 3 years ago
Listen closely she OBVIOUSLY says "Stoneman's calvary" AND "In the winter or 65".
Perhaps you need a hearing aid?
Anyway, Joan is a good singer and all, but she is a bitch in real life.
timlearybedead 3 years ago
Oh i know in this version she does, in the original cover she did, she doesn't, I remember I commented on the wrong video mate.
rikhurley 3 years ago
Ah yes I checked it and you're right. I read on Wiki that she didn't even know the lyrics when she recorded it, she just sung what she thought she heard lol.
timlearybedead 3 years ago
lol, meh when your so coked up, I'm sure it sounded perfectly normal to her lol.
rikhurley 3 years ago
Is this the comatose version?
4evrblu 3 years ago
superb
ranchoboyeros 3 years ago
wonderful
songwriter92 3 years ago
I see she still hasn't bothered to learn the words.
Pat2296 3 years ago
She got some of them right. At least she says "stoneman's cavalry" now.
-jcr
NSResponder 3 years ago
such a good job. i truely love this song. and you guys did an amazing job.
southernman517 3 years ago
Hey, I was there!
I forgot she butchered this song....
NthgToFear 3 years ago 2
This is a really quiet video.
whotookaegir 3 years ago
danke
busmaster1 3 years ago
dpicc77 you're the greatest ZERO alive..
Calinn86 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
boooooooooooooooooooooooo you suck
dpicc77 4 years ago
This song is about pride even if the south lost the pople were never defeated, Thats how iv'e always seen it anyway.
Dogstar333 4 years ago 9
@Dogstar333 Deo Vindice
12thSTARvideo 1 year ago
@Dogstar333 of course they weren't defeated, in their minds. But of course they took revenge on the innocent black population for more than a hundred years by passing very racist, segregationist and discriminatory laws (jim crow). As long as your people were and still able to make black people suffer they'd still believe that they weren't defeated. Thank God for Abe Lincoln and Martin Luther King Jr.
KChery 1 year ago
@KChery As is they were treated 'so well' in the North the last 100 years... at least tell the whole story. Plenty of Slavery existed in the North. Up until the late 1830's, only one place in the U.S. sold more slaves than Charleston---- New York City.
57mab 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KChery As if they were treated 'so well' in the North the last 100 years... at least tell the whole story. Plenty of Slavery existed in the North. Up until the late 1830's, only one place in the U.S. sold more slaves than Charleston---- New York City.
57mab 10 months ago
excellent. this is such a good song.
southernman516 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
this fucking sucks only the band can sing it
dpicc77 4 years ago
Love you Joan - you're a gem.
Saskia
Australia
SaskiaCornell 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck her tho... shes too self righteous
mrbill224 4 years ago
And you're a flaming asshole
mthivier 4 years ago
incredible insight, messiah. history repeats itself like a bad fart. war is never about selfdefense. it is about a handfull of leaders, who lied to get elected and then revealed their true colors to accomplish their own selfish pursuits, at the expense of a mass of misdirected youth they call - g.i.'s
chpumpkin 4 years ago
trapping black people in an inescapable cycle of slavery? you're claiming that 'welfare' is the reason that people are poor? "do some research".....hmmmmm. i would say that you need to take your own advice. socialism has ..very little to do with welfare. one can have welfare capitalism, but it's still capitalism. socialism is the public ownership of the means of production. oy ve..
honestkaos 4 years ago
I was refering to the modern white supremacist view of adopting the old Confederacy songs and symbols for political propaganda purposes. The songs and flags historically have had little to do with those things both the far Right and Far left alike have claimed they represent.
LC65 4 years ago
Nice, but I am surprised she is singing that song. She is such a liberal progresive spokes person that I did not think that she could sing a song symbolic of old Confederacy (slavery and conservative values).
LC65 4 years ago
Slavery is not a conservative or political value.
She sings it because it's the only good song she ever did. Other than this song her music is crap.
RicPhlare 4 years ago
So is your opinion.
mthivier 4 years ago
this song has nothing to do with slavery. conservative values have nothing to do with this song, either. There is a lot more to the fall of the old south than slavery and what you call "conservatve" values, and that is why this song has been covered by Baez, Johnny Cash, The Black Crowes, Vendetta Red, Bruce Hornsby, Jerry Garcia, The Decemberists. It is a song about heritage. get your stereotypical head out of the gutter.
hereweare23 4 years ago
Slavery is not a conservative value. However traping black people in a neverending, unexscapable cycle of socialist slavery through welfare appers to be a liberal value.
Do some research, nobody who died in the civil war owned a slave.
djl1980 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what are you fucking stupid? im hoping this was a joke.... if not id like to see the extent of your own research
mrbill224 4 years ago
Thanks for posting I love. Her performance of In My Time of need from the same show used to be on Youtube and it's amazing too.
taddyd1 4 years ago