@junkyman19571 You are a class A dick! We as a people have no control over what our ancestors do in the past. I suppose all americans should pay dearly for "allowing" their ancestors to buy, sell, and brutally hang black people 120 years ago. By the way I am american, but I love German culture and the german people. I've been studying the language for 3 months. Your an idiot und jetzt verpiss dich.
@RWT683 I'm Portuguese, but I lived 4 months in Berlin and when walking in the center of the city, of each 10 persons I saw, I think 1 or 2 were asians (almost didn't saw any black person). I RARELY saw people who weren't German.
My gosh, do the trolls just wait day and night to destroy YouTube threads. I lived in Bavaria and Swabia for 4 years and never met friendlier people outside of Holland and Austrailia (probably the friendliest places on earth). My only problem with Germans is thier anemic birthrates. If trends continue, Germany will lose 25 million people by 2052. It's a crying shame. But then again, New York, Vermont, and Taxeschussets have birthrates even lower.
@jpkoch1962 I know. It is like for each video concerning any sort of ethnic matter there is a never ending supply of white supremacists to spew their hatred (either masked as white pride, or outright harassment). Where are these people's humanity or compassion? It makes me sick to see all this hatred when I just want to enrich my knowledge of the world's various cultures!
As for that jerk who decided to put hitler into the forefront of the discussion, he's being an idiot. This is a nice little song about a beautiful girl in the Black Forest, and I enjoy it very much, thank you for uploading it.
you fucking nazi bastards,you didn't get a tenth of what you deserved...my how you shit yourselves when the russians were heading towards you..with the idea of dishing out to you what you did FIRST....should have left you to them....and we could've had a nice national park where germany used to be.....oh and you started the FIRST WORLD WAR but thats for another time..
@junkman19571 Can you explain to me how German people of today are Nazis.The British sluatered millions of Africans and Natives.Does that make you a serial killer?
@junkman19571 lol. you might not have studied everything. it was a well done corruption when the republic had its weaknesses. but history... study more german history of what happened before and after. it is not forgotten what happened. i see lots of memories for the jews around here. it is not the nazis are no more. this word "nazi" is defined by some facts which do not fit to the german country since 1945.
@junkman19571 look at USA today. they kill 10 civillians before they kill one terrorist. they are just war fanatics i know american veterans who wish that they never went to the middle east because they had to see innocent people die. but the so called super powers can easily overshadow this kind of facts. the american soldiers from WW2 were not like "oh fuvk nazi die". they even had peaceful conversations with captured german soldiers because they understood. every country has his bad stories
@junkman19571 btw he wasnt voted in order to rule the world. it had something to do with the crisis in the twenties. people didnt trust in the old republic anymore and hitler presented himself as a hero helping out of this. changing laws every month and controling the media helped him corrupting the country step by step. when there was any protoest against him the SA silenced them
now this is a video about german children singing who have nothing to do with all of that. history is missplaced
@junkman19571 I don't see why the hell people of German DESCENT should be bothered with what happened in their culture's past. I'm extremely proud of my German heritage, and I'm not afraid to show it. But the hilarious thing is, I'm also part Russian. So, yeah. Your post would've made me laugh if it wasn't so fucking obnoxious and rude. And honestly, yeah, Germany has had it's problems. Just like ANY OTHER COUNTRY. So get over yourself and think before you post something as fucking rude as that.
@iamtheanimegirl Way to stand up for yourself. At least I'm not the only one who thinks racist idiots should keep their hands off of their keyboards. XD
greenfellow 1966...the germans voted him into power,were only to glad to think they could/would rule the world.......only changed their views on him when things went rotten..what the GERMANS did to the jews and others should never be forgot.and they should pay reparations for ad infinitum.and don't say its a different generation,what was done was done and by the GERMANS...
In response to the comments made here, it's important to realise that Hitler corrupted German folklore and culture for political ends. Culture and mythology are a source of immense national pride (not a bad thing) in one's country on the one hand and a dangerous political tool on the other. It's perfectly possible to celebrate German folk music, history and culture without any mention of Nazism or Hitler, but some choose otherwise for their own sick source of amusement.
@BritainAwake2oo8 If you consider enslaving his country men for the sake of keeping his little vision alive good then you need help... the results economically and technologically are good, but the methods used to reach those ends are horrible and vile.
@Elberiver11 You are totally correct.. They are so fucking annoying, They have nothing else to say but slag other countries.. Their the ones with No history.. Therefore no fucking folk music. They have to remember that We are the ones that founded their land.
that is all a lie a not every one thinks all that i find that rude on both sides 1 for the americans saying that Germans are all evil and all these other bad things. and i also find it Rude that people from Germany call the americans stupid back. Why are we all fighting about this i say who ever made this video needs to take out the comments all this video is doing is sparking a debate
Talking about Hitler, or refering to a german a "dirty nazi" is like, going in the us and saying 9-11 rules. No big difference. Germans have pretty much ERASED hitler from their history, and public society views, as it's a big black scar in their nation.
Another thing, if you say America has 'history' all I see is 300 years of killing NATIVE PEOPLE and stealing their LANDS.
Hab mehrmals versucht eine Meinung hierher zu tippen, dann muss ich immer diese bloede Buchstaben, die ich nicht gut lesen kann, zurueck tippen bevor es weiter geht.
@Elberiver11 Oh that's just random people trying to start trouble. Don't lump all English and Americans in the same boat, otherwise you're just as bad as the people trying to start trouble. I love folk music, but these kids don't seem so happy to be singing. xD
@Cstrife234 what? The Germans are just as bad as those Angloamericans who keep fouling our nation, just because they do not agree with it? What kind of nutter are you?
You are trying to tell me that these people were an exception, well go and confront reality, you joker. EVERY FILM on Youtube, and i mean EVERY film that deals with non-political issues like Folk songs or whatever, is fouled by americans, britons and poles. This is not my imagination, mate, but reality..
You people from those so-called "innocent nations" should stop fouling the whole German nation as "dirty Nazis". Look at your own histoy, the Americans and British killed far more innocents than the Nazis did, but funnily enough this seems to be no problem AT ALL to your countries.
We in Germany have a saying: "Sweep before your own door first", i think you "blameless nations" would be well advised to do that before fouling your neighbour!
@@Cstrife234 and its NOT random people, the Americans and British and many other nations believe they have the right to insult us and portray my whole country as "villains", its funny how your country never depicted the Russians as "evil people" for Stalin's crimes (which were supported by Churhcill and Roosevelt by the way), but they depict the whole German nation as "villains".
From the Angloamericans of all people! Who behaved like the biggest villains themselves!
@Elberiver11 It is because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
@Elberiver11 It is because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
@Elberiver11 what they do is so sick and moronic as to talk to them about Hiroshima or the Klu Klux Klan in a bluegrass or country video. Folk music is a part of the best every country has, no need to talk about the worst when people are enjoying it.
Getting on the topic of people hating Germany for hitler, uhmmm... the Germans hate Hitler too Dumbasses! he ruined the reputation for this wonderful place. but lusckily the great people of germany rebuilt that reputation. good job germany!!!!! ich liebe dich!
Wenn ihr nur über Rassismus reden wollt dann geht auf Hitler Seiten, aber nicht auf Seiten wo Kinder ein völlig unrassistisches Lied singen. Diese Zeiten sind 70 Jahre her. Sie waren nicht schön, aber wenn man 70 Jahre danach alle Deutschen anklagt sie wären Massenmörder kan ich das nicht verstehen. Die echten Massenmörder beziffern sich auf ungefähr 1000. Deutschland hat 83 Mio Einwohner!!
@Elberiver11 Yes. We Americans are generally quite socially twisted and ill. Sorry. My family is from Germany and I took a bit of abuse about it in grade school.
ARGGGGG!!!!! America, the country of immigrants and tollerance. I am ashamed as I read some of these comments. Why would you search out and watch innocent children singing an old folk song only to make these nasty comments? Hush yourselves.
@Elberiver11 I'm an American, but I have no problem with Germans or anyone else. I actually plan on going back to Germany one of these days and visit where I was born. :)
America and Britain are warcriminals, the reason why they love to insult Germans and call this song a "NAZI SONG",. is because they want to distract from their OWN FAR WORSE crimes!
America and the British Empire murdered over ONE MILLION INNOCENTS in German cities, mostly women and children. They BURNT AND BURIED THEM ALIVE.
@Elberiver11 As I said earlier we did what we had to to win a war. Don't start taking the moral high ground with me, I do believe that there 6 million jews dead because of Germany. Besides Germany knew we were allies with the British, and the French. So attacking them was all but a declaration of war on us, and then your ally the japanese attacked our homeland. As I said earlier I agree with you on everything just dont blame us for winning a war.
@Elberiver11 "THEY BURNT AND BURIED THEM ALIVE". Wow do I have to remind you that Nazis burned and gassed jews, even children your acting like Germans are innocent.
@Generatorsarefake Not all Germans. Not even all of the Nazi's did any of those things. Don't you think Americans have killed or tortured anyone in during war? And during peace? The children in this video certainly didn't burn or bury anyone. You are embarrassing your American comrades with your ignorance.
@aalethian You don't know whats going on. We were having an arguement. He's a racist bastard. Look at his channel comments you'll see what I'm talking about. I don't know why people reply to me if I posted that comments a month ago..
Elberiver11 ! Don't give a damn about those stupid Americans and English. They only know the 'dark' side of Hitler (camps, genocide,etc.), but they tend to forget that it was he, who reorganised Germany after he came to power. Large-scale constructions (roads, schools,hospitals,etc.) took place and most of the population was happy with his leadership. So, just ignore these Arschkopfs. Greetings from Hungary ! Preserve what is rightfully yours: the songs, stories, poems and the land as well.
@karpala666 I agree with you. Jó napot kívánok. Köszönöm! Magyar-német barátság!
PS: Austria-Hungaria was great success, great Empire over many hundreds of years. Allies were JEALOUS, this is why they destroyed it in 1919. Spirit lives on !!!
@Elberiver11 - agreed, you cant even say Germany in America without it being responded with Hitler. Cant even show a tad bit of pride of the German civilization without being labeled a Nazi. Hell, Can't even have tattoos of the Runes without being called a Nazi...its over with people..lots of love from Pennsylvania Dutch.
German ppl are very nice :)) I love your culture!! i don't care what was in the past, I don't care who killed whom!! Yes, these wars were very big mistakes, yes, the Germans killed my great grandfather-that's true! BUT it was in past!! Everything has changed. I know that Germans realize everything and they're not thinking about bad days of past years... The Germans are great people! YES, YOU SHOULD BE PROUD OF YOUR COUNTRY!!! LOTS OF LOVE FROM GEORGIA!! LOVE& P E A C E !!!!
@momogoesrawwwr too bad, but there's lots of people in America that respects and even admires Germans for their culture and music, take me for example ;)
@Elberiver11 Das ist nich normal, those americans always judge people while in there own country after world war two and before there's more racism then in the rest of the world, they never expirienced a war on there own soil after the civil war.
I am American and am very proud of my German heritage. (So please refer to these idiots only as Stupid people and leave the nationality out of it.) Germany is rich in culture and beauty. Most everyone I have met there has been warm, accommodating, and genuine.
Anyone who visits there will enjoy it very much. If not, it is their own fault. This is a sweet song performed by children and political discussions have no place here. Let's enjoy our differences and this song. Viel Spaß!
@Elberiver11 In America people connect "German" with "NAZI" even though the war ended more than 60 yrs ago. just ignore the fuckers because clearly they are plain ignorant.
Your folks should stop insulting my country. How many Germans have you seen, mocking 9/11? I haven't seen any.
But i see Americans gloating over the 600 000 German women & children they killed in Roosevelt's wicked Firestorm-Holocausts in German cities. Remember, the Germans never attacked any city in the USA and never killed any American child or woman. The USA had no right to wipe our cities off the map and to kill over half a million of our mothers & children.
And its even more strange that Americans insult us even today, now that the war is history, as you said yourself. Also very strange: America killed far more innocents in the Red-Indian Holocaust than Hitler killed Jews. And yet America has thousand Holocaust memorials with the aim to insult Germany - but they dont have a memorial for their own holocaust. I think this is most peculiar.
Americans do no seem to know that Hitler was only possible because America and Britain prepared the ground for Fascism at Versailles 1919. Millions of Germans were occupied by hostile Aliens and Enemy forces. Hitler drove them out, which is the reason for his success. If the Americans and Britons had not enslaved Germany under Tyranny of Aliens, Hitler would not have happened.
Most Americans do not seem to know, that America started WW II with Germany - not the other way round.
@Elberiver11 Its true that we set the ground work for Hitler. Its also true that we did in our own way have a holocaust, and maybe we are thumbing our noses at you by puting up holocaust memorials. But dont EVER blame us for doing what we had to do to win a war. I dont remember you being to gentle with Paris, or London, or Stalingrad. Now, lets enjoy the music and ignore our friends who insist on fighting.
@zegermandude "Not gentle" with Paris or London? LOL Paris is undestroyed, bnecause a "bad nazi saved it. London started bombing Germany - Gemany bombed London back. Go buy a history book, fool.
And you being from America should not talk about cities not being handled" gently" - your satanist worshipping president Roosevfelt wiped whole cities off the map. Ever heard of Hamburg? A city the area size of London. But london had a few broken houses, but half of Hamburg was WIPED OUT.
@zegermandude you murdered over 40 000 children and women in only three nights - you called the mass execution of civilians "Operation Gomorrha". Compare that to the few 380 civilians in Coventry. And note that the Germans wer decent people, not crooks like you British bastards, because they targeted Coventry which was centre of the BRITISH WAR INDUSTRY. But the Americns and British targeted HOSPITAL CITIES like DRESDEN. Dresden was a HOLOCAUOST, dude, so shut up.
Germans have caused the jews so much pain, they starved them too death, and even gassed them, after that they cremated the bodies. They killed about 6 millions Jews. He tried to kill the russians to own their land as well. Fuck Hitler, I hope he burns in hell for all the pain he has caused.
@Generatorsarefake yeah....i don't want to negote that, but what the fuck, this is 60 years PASSED now....i didn't do it! don't blame whole generations for something that happened in the past...
@Mo0onwalker It was Hitler who did it no one said it was you, by Germans I meant Nazis. Certain events that have happened in the past can always be remembered. I'm not saying Germans are bad, all I'm saying is about what happened. I don't care if it was 60 years ago, my point is that it HAPPENED and never will be forgotten. One more thing, don't insult people by calling them bs for example "douche".
@Generatorsarefake i won't say it didn't happen....i am very sorry for what happened in those years, but at one point i have to say: this wasn't me...no one blames at a "30 seconds to mars" video 'americans' for vietnam war...for gods sake, this is about the black forest, this song was written before world war II....so what is the problem here? if you want to discuss about hitler, go to a forum, but don't shout "german nazis" at a youtube video about black forest...
@Generatorsarefake Another moron who tries to insult the Germans......who are you to insult them? An American racist?
You want to REMEMBER WHAT HAPPENED? Then remember how your Kukluxklan-grandfather murdered Black people and how he exterminated 58 Million RED INDIANS of North America. .Thats what HAPPENED...
But what does your crimes in America have to do with a GERMAN Song, sung by German children, you racist idiot? Nothing. So, fuck off and spread your hate somewhere else. Racist.
@Elberiver11 American racist? No, I was talking about the past events of what happened. I did not insult the Germans of today I insulted the Nazi's. You also have no right to call America a "global massmurder". It was in the PAST which I was talking about. There are still Germans who are racist and Americans as well. So, fuck off and spread YOUR ignorance elsewhere.
@Elberiver11 You shouldn't be calling other people racist, when your the racist one insulting people over the Internet as seen on your channel comments. I saw two comments that said awful things on your channel. You should learn from what you replied to me. I forgot to mention earlier, that your racist land wanted to make only one race GERMAN, they wanted to exterminate any race that wasn't German. So as I said earlier you have no right to call America a "global massmurder".
@Elberiver11 If they weren't stopped they would of continued with their desire to make one race. Even you know it, I'm not saying America is the best race in the world I was just talking about what happened, yes you are right about the murder of what happened in America, but by what you are saying you think its a land of death, do I have to remind you that nazis killed about 6 million jewish people and were going to continue.
@Mo0onwalker Ich würde mit diesen Leuten gar nicht gross diskutieren. Schon gar nicht mit diesem Britisch-Amerikanischen Gesindel, die haben doch die Indianer ausgerottet. Sie ermordeten millionen.
@Generatorsarefake JEWS? hahaha, what a moron you are. What about the 3.0 Million Germans you starved to death, you American racists?
Remember you started war on Germany before they declared war back on you, and remember you exterminated the Native Americans - first Holocaust in history.
America is built on theft, blood and murder: America EXTERMINATED THE INDIANS.
America is a global massmurderer, America had racist segregation until the 1960ies, Black people had to go to University under POLICE PROTECTION, because otherwise the white American MOB would haev murdered them. THATS AMERICA - Racism, massmurder and hidden Holocausts.
Reply part #4 To anujxs1: lyrics--cont. das Mädel im Schwarzwälder Tal. the girl in the Black Forrest valley.) _____________________ Wir reichten zum Abschied noch einmal die Hand (We reached out our hands once again for farewell und wünschten einander viel Glück and wished each other good luck) und wo ich geh' und steh (and wherever I go or stand (cont...)
With loves from Turkey. My country have always believed the Germany could win 1. and 2. world wars. We shared the same faith in the 1. world war. But the allies was too crowded. Even a lion can not fight against a group of jackals. You guys even did very bravely. My congratulations..
continued: Because we don't need you and never will. Look at your own short and miserable history and look at what you did to the Red Indians!! I rest my case!
And the British shouldn't be so smug either, you committed your fair share of attrocities and murders in your empire's colonies, so, like the Americans, leave us Germans the hell alone. (This obviously only goes out to stupid and narrow-minded Americans and British, as 90% of you are amazing and I love being in England)
I'm a German living in England and I have to say it's making me sick not being able to watch a single German video on here without some idiot discussing the Third Reich! 1933-1945, that's 12 years!! 12 bad years in the history of Germany, which has 50 times more history and culture than any of you American dickheads could ever imagine. Gosh, it must be so sad and depressing to live in a country like America, without culture and history. So stay the fuck there and leave us Germans the hell alone!
You Anglo-American idiots should better start dealing with your own Holocausts and warcriminals, you have plenty of them, lots of work to do for you! So leave us alone with your Hitler/Holocaust shit! And deal with your own crimes! Idiots. How disgusting, you can't even go to a simple FOLK SONG, without being molested by these sick anglo-americans and their HITLER discussions! This fucking SUCKS.
Reply part #2 To anujxs1: the lyrics--cont: im Tal und auf der Höh (in the valley or on the heights Da liegt mir die Mühle, die Mühle im Sinn (the mill, the mill remains in my mind— die Mühle im Schwarzwälder Tal. the mill in the Black Forrest valley.) _____________________ Und in dieser Mühle im Schwarzwälder Tal (And in this mill in the Black Forrest valley (cont...)
Langweiliger geht's wirklich nicht mehr! - Kartenspiel während des Singens ? - Wo gibt es so etwas? - Wer ein Lied vorträgt, sollte es - mit Text und guter Stimme - überzeugend rüber bringen! - Oder man lässt es sein, bei YouTube zu veröffentlichen, bevor man sich gänzlich blamiert!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think this song is about a godam jew trying to buy some young girls while the men are off to war.she won't sell , they won't go , but he does not shut his fukin' jewish piehole!
It's either that or he's trying to sell some baby kittens...
I LOVE EUROPEAN CULTURE!
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
Comment removed
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
Comment removed
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
Comment removed
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
Comment removed
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
Nice song,greeting from Serbia!!!
SuperTulumba 1 week ago
@junkyman19571 You are a class A dick! We as a people have no control over what our ancestors do in the past. I suppose all americans should pay dearly for "allowing" their ancestors to buy, sell, and brutally hang black people 120 years ago. By the way I am american, but I love German culture and the german people. I've been studying the language for 3 months. Your an idiot und jetzt verpiss dich.
Deutschland2102 3 weeks ago
发现德国的小孩儿都好看得很。。
673346509 1 month ago
The sad thing is, they had to collect little white girls from the four corners of Germany to have enough to make this. This is all they could find.
Verzeihung....hat das "rechtsextremistisch" geklingt? Lech mich.
White people of the world wake the fuck up to the lies, or be exterminated.
Deutschen, NPD wählen oder den Tod. Eure Entscheidung.
RWT683 1 month ago
@RWT683 calm the fuck down
0megadwarf 1 month ago
@RWT683 I'm Portuguese, but I lived 4 months in Berlin and when walking in the center of the city, of each 10 persons I saw, I think 1 or 2 were asians (almost didn't saw any black person). I RARELY saw people who weren't German.
VeranzaTheKing 1 day ago
AIGHT
MsBorntobeme 1 month ago
very nice!
schnefsky 2 months ago
Sehr schön und dazu gibt es noch schöne Schwarzwaldtrachten!
dominiquedv 2 months ago
the best song of german folk I heard till now and still looking some more like maybe the lamb ballad
IUVENTIU 4 months ago
for every body trying to say that this is nazi music... its not if you do anything related to nazi germany you get a minimum of 10 years in prison
mudjugXdipper 5 months ago
What a sweet children's program! Well done! As for the trolls, there is a special place in hell for them.
derrydownbeat 5 months ago
My gosh, do the trolls just wait day and night to destroy YouTube threads. I lived in Bavaria and Swabia for 4 years and never met friendlier people outside of Holland and Austrailia (probably the friendliest places on earth). My only problem with Germans is thier anemic birthrates. If trends continue, Germany will lose 25 million people by 2052. It's a crying shame. But then again, New York, Vermont, and Taxeschussets have birthrates even lower.
jpkoch1962 5 months ago 2
@jpkoch1962 I know. It is like for each video concerning any sort of ethnic matter there is a never ending supply of white supremacists to spew their hatred (either masked as white pride, or outright harassment). Where are these people's humanity or compassion? It makes me sick to see all this hatred when I just want to enrich my knowledge of the world's various cultures!
0megadwarf 1 month ago
stfu with the nazi bullshits.
killlkd 6 months ago
What a beautiful song!
MrBurdett007 8 months ago
@SuperiorPeter why encourage him to further this idiocy?
ESLynnette 8 months ago
As for that jerk who decided to put hitler into the forefront of the discussion, he's being an idiot. This is a nice little song about a beautiful girl in the Black Forest, and I enjoy it very much, thank you for uploading it.
ESLynnette 8 months ago
Süss !!!
Gwynsek 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
not all germans are nazis ! the people now living in Germany, also have relatives and lost everything
smilingKiwiXD 9 months ago
not all germans are nazis ! the people now living in Germany, also have relatives and lost everything
smilingKiwiXD 9 months ago
Hello, I am interested to hear also some other germaneese folk songs, what would you recommend me?
P.S. - I like that one, and the hats are cool <3
WaterfallOfLife 10 months ago
you fucking nazi bastards,you didn't get a tenth of what you deserved...my how you shit yourselves when the russians were heading towards you..with the idea of dishing out to you what you did FIRST....should have left you to them....and we could've had a nice national park where germany used to be.....oh and you started the FIRST WORLD WAR but thats for another time..
junkman19571 10 months ago
@junkman19571 Can you explain to me how German people of today are Nazis.The British sluatered millions of Africans and Natives.Does that make you a serial killer?
doggydeeds 7 months ago
@doggydeeds and put afrikaans women and children in concentration camps where they starved to death.
padookieking 7 months ago
@junkman19571 lol. you might not have studied everything. it was a well done corruption when the republic had its weaknesses. but history... study more german history of what happened before and after. it is not forgotten what happened. i see lots of memories for the jews around here. it is not the nazis are no more. this word "nazi" is defined by some facts which do not fit to the german country since 1945.
Garother 4 months ago
@junkman19571 look at USA today. they kill 10 civillians before they kill one terrorist. they are just war fanatics i know american veterans who wish that they never went to the middle east because they had to see innocent people die. but the so called super powers can easily overshadow this kind of facts. the american soldiers from WW2 were not like "oh fuvk nazi die". they even had peaceful conversations with captured german soldiers because they understood. every country has his bad stories
Garother 4 months ago
@junkman19571 btw he wasnt voted in order to rule the world. it had something to do with the crisis in the twenties. people didnt trust in the old republic anymore and hitler presented himself as a hero helping out of this. changing laws every month and controling the media helped him corrupting the country step by step. when there was any protoest against him the SA silenced them
now this is a video about german children singing who have nothing to do with all of that. history is missplaced
Garother 4 months ago
@junkman19571 I don't see why the hell people of German DESCENT should be bothered with what happened in their culture's past. I'm extremely proud of my German heritage, and I'm not afraid to show it. But the hilarious thing is, I'm also part Russian. So, yeah. Your post would've made me laugh if it wasn't so fucking obnoxious and rude. And honestly, yeah, Germany has had it's problems. Just like ANY OTHER COUNTRY. So get over yourself and think before you post something as fucking rude as that.
iamtheanimegirl 4 months ago
@iamtheanimegirl Way to stand up for yourself. At least I'm not the only one who thinks racist idiots should keep their hands off of their keyboards. XD
Falcon4761 3 weeks ago
greenfellow 1966...the germans voted him into power,were only to glad to think they could/would rule the world.......only changed their views on him when things went rotten..what the GERMANS did to the jews and others should never be forgot.and they should pay reparations for ad infinitum.and don't say its a different generation,what was done was done and by the GERMANS...
junkman19571 10 months ago
all i can say is they are terrible singers
briibearr1 10 months ago
In response to the comments made here, it's important to realise that Hitler corrupted German folklore and culture for political ends. Culture and mythology are a source of immense national pride (not a bad thing) in one's country on the one hand and a dangerous political tool on the other. It's perfectly possible to celebrate German folk music, history and culture without any mention of Nazism or Hitler, but some choose otherwise for their own sick source of amusement.
greenfellow1966 10 months ago
GOTT DAS ES SOWAS NOCH GIBT!!! ICH WEINE VOR FREUDE !:D
Und ich als 19 jähriger!
KULTUR BEIBEHALTEN! GERADE WO ES AM SCHWERSTEN ERSCHEINT IST ES AM NOTWENDIGSTEN!
allmightyism 11 months ago 11
Wie schön, daß den jungen Leuten hier noch traditionelle Kultur vermittelt wird, vorbildlich.
HeinrichDerTreue 11 months ago
nobody in Germany knows that fucking song!!! what's that shit????
and: this children should learn singing before they do it!!!!><
lovelychest 11 months ago
@BritainAwake2oo8 If you consider enslaving his country men for the sake of keeping his little vision alive good then you need help... the results economically and technologically are good, but the methods used to reach those ends are horrible and vile.
S0ryiu 11 months ago
@Elberiver11 Hey...I didn't do anything. I just love folk music. :3 *umarmen* Ich bin ein Chicagoer.
Cstrife234 11 months ago
Ich lerne Deutsch und das ist sehr gut! Ich liebe es (I think that's grammatically correct).
hhppllaa 11 months ago
@Elberiver11 You are totally correct.. They are so fucking annoying, They have nothing else to say but slag other countries.. Their the ones with No history.. Therefore no fucking folk music. They have to remember that We are the ones that founded their land.
Fantastische Musik, Danke :)
UnwirklichACDC 11 months ago
that is all a lie a not every one thinks all that i find that rude on both sides 1 for the americans saying that Germans are all evil and all these other bad things. and i also find it Rude that people from Germany call the americans stupid back. Why are we all fighting about this i say who ever made this video needs to take out the comments all this video is doing is sparking a debate
whocaresitsdancetime 1 year ago
Lets switch views.
Talking about Hitler, or refering to a german a "dirty nazi" is like, going in the us and saying 9-11 rules. No big difference. Germans have pretty much ERASED hitler from their history, and public society views, as it's a big black scar in their nation.
Another thing, if you say America has 'history' all I see is 300 years of killing NATIVE PEOPLE and stealing their LANDS.
GF america.
Cakit0o 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cakit0o
"Another thing, if you say America has 'history' all I see is 300 years of killing NATIVE PEOPLE and stealing their LANDS."
Really that's it? You must really be delusional. Do you imagine yourself living in a castle too? Do you slay dragons?
patio87 11 months ago
Comment removed
chakravampir 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cakit0o
THAT, if they americans HAVE ANY history at all.
chakravampir 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cakit0o
THAT, if they americans HAVE ANY history at all.
bunch of rootless people who have nothing called past to learn from.
chakravampir 11 months ago
@Elberiver11
the sad part is a lot of amerikans don`t even know what ANGLO refers to.
mciceteade 1 year ago
Hab mehrmals versucht eine Meinung hierher zu tippen, dann muss ich immer diese bloede Buchstaben, die ich nicht gut lesen kann, zurueck tippen bevor es weiter geht.
ServusGrueziHallo 1 year ago
test
ServusGrueziHallo 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 Oh that's just random people trying to start trouble. Don't lump all English and Americans in the same boat, otherwise you're just as bad as the people trying to start trouble. I love folk music, but these kids don't seem so happy to be singing. xD
Cstrife234 1 year ago
@Cstrife234 what? The Germans are just as bad as those Angloamericans who keep fouling our nation, just because they do not agree with it? What kind of nutter are you?
You are trying to tell me that these people were an exception, well go and confront reality, you joker. EVERY FILM on Youtube, and i mean EVERY film that deals with non-political issues like Folk songs or whatever, is fouled by americans, britons and poles. This is not my imagination, mate, but reality..
Elberiver11 1 year ago
You people from those so-called "innocent nations" should stop fouling the whole German nation as "dirty Nazis". Look at your own histoy, the Americans and British killed far more innocents than the Nazis did, but funnily enough this seems to be no problem AT ALL to your countries.
We in Germany have a saying: "Sweep before your own door first", i think you "blameless nations" would be well advised to do that before fouling your neighbour!
And the kids,. they are shy, what do you expect!
Elberiver11 1 year ago
@@Cstrife234 and its NOT random people, the Americans and British and many other nations believe they have the right to insult us and portray my whole country as "villains", its funny how your country never depicted the Russians as "evil people" for Stalin's crimes (which were supported by Churhcill and Roosevelt by the way), but they depict the whole German nation as "villains".
From the Angloamericans of all people! Who behaved like the biggest villains themselves!
Elberiver11 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Elberiver11 It is because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
oh wait...
galen64 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
oh wait...
galen64 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Elberiver11 It is because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
oh wait...
galen64 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Because unlike yours, our beloved Anglo-American culture is not stained by the embarrassing mar of racism, colonialism or warmongering...
oh wait...
galen64 1 year ago
Comment removed
galen64 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 what they do is so sick and moronic as to talk to them about Hiroshima or the Klu Klux Klan in a bluegrass or country video. Folk music is a part of the best every country has, no need to talk about the worst when people are enjoying it.
DiegoElArbol 1 year ago
Getting on the topic of people hating Germany for hitler, uhmmm... the Germans hate Hitler too Dumbasses! he ruined the reputation for this wonderful place. but lusckily the great people of germany rebuilt that reputation. good job germany!!!!! ich liebe dich!
indiekid531 1 year ago 3
oh my good lord , every time there is any slightest hint of germany on any youtube
video , "THERE HAS TO BE DISCUSSION ABOUT THE NAZIS AND HITLER"
i pity these wonderful people are always remembered in the negative way.
GET A LIFE IDIOTS , your discussions cannot change the past !!!
TheBarathbushan 1 year ago 3
STFU ABOUT NAZIS! FUCKING KIDS FOLK SONG
ghillienig 1 year ago
@ghillienig
Why is it a f***ing kids folk song ? I like it !
ColaPac 1 year ago
Wenn ihr nur über Rassismus reden wollt dann geht auf Hitler Seiten, aber nicht auf Seiten wo Kinder ein völlig unrassistisches Lied singen. Diese Zeiten sind 70 Jahre her. Sie waren nicht schön, aber wenn man 70 Jahre danach alle Deutschen anklagt sie wären Massenmörder kan ich das nicht verstehen. Die echten Massenmörder beziffern sich auf ungefähr 1000. Deutschland hat 83 Mio Einwohner!!
rocker77723 1 year ago 3
Wundervoll
Corpsegrinder92666 1 year ago
Keep the bullshit out of this. We only want to here our cultural music, you evil pricks.
dannyhill1971lives 1 year ago 8
@Elberiver11 Yes. We Americans are generally quite socially twisted and ill. Sorry. My family is from Germany and I took a bit of abuse about it in grade school.
aalethian 1 year ago
ARGGGGG!!!!! America, the country of immigrants and tollerance. I am ashamed as I read some of these comments. Why would you search out and watch innocent children singing an old folk song only to make these nasty comments? Hush yourselves.
Apration 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 I'm an American, but I have no problem with Germans or anyone else. I actually plan on going back to Germany one of these days and visit where I was born. :)
Valkickawesum62 1 year ago
America and Britain are warcriminals, the reason why they love to insult Germans and call this song a "NAZI SONG",. is because they want to distract from their OWN FAR WORSE crimes!
America and the British Empire murdered over ONE MILLION INNOCENTS in German cities, mostly women and children. They BURNT AND BURIED THEM ALIVE.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 As I said earlier we did what we had to to win a war. Don't start taking the moral high ground with me, I do believe that there 6 million jews dead because of Germany. Besides Germany knew we were allies with the British, and the French. So attacking them was all but a declaration of war on us, and then your ally the japanese attacked our homeland. As I said earlier I agree with you on everything just dont blame us for winning a war.
zegermandude 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 "THEY BURNT AND BURIED THEM ALIVE". Wow do I have to remind you that Nazis burned and gassed jews, even children your acting like Germans are innocent.
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Generatorsarefake Not all Germans. Not even all of the Nazi's did any of those things. Don't you think Americans have killed or tortured anyone in during war? And during peace? The children in this video certainly didn't burn or bury anyone. You are embarrassing your American comrades with your ignorance.
aalethian 1 year ago
@aalethian You don't know whats going on. We were having an arguement. He's a racist bastard. Look at his channel comments you'll see what I'm talking about. I don't know why people reply to me if I posted that comments a month ago..
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
Elberiver11 ! Don't give a damn about those stupid Americans and English. They only know the 'dark' side of Hitler (camps, genocide,etc.), but they tend to forget that it was he, who reorganised Germany after he came to power. Large-scale constructions (roads, schools,hospitals,etc.) took place and most of the population was happy with his leadership. So, just ignore these Arschkopfs. Greetings from Hungary ! Preserve what is rightfully yours: the songs, stories, poems and the land as well.
karpala666 1 year ago
@karpala666 I agree with you. Jó napot kívánok. Köszönöm! Magyar-német barátság!
PS: Austria-Hungaria was great success, great Empire over many hundreds of years. Allies were JEALOUS, this is why they destroyed it in 1919. Spirit lives on !!!
Elberiver11 1 year ago
ich liebe deutschland! lots of love from Canada! i wish my ancestors didnt have to leave Germany
djclue2001 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 - agreed, you cant even say Germany in America without it being responded with Hitler. Cant even show a tad bit of pride of the German civilization without being labeled a Nazi. Hell, Can't even have tattoos of the Runes without being called a Nazi...its over with people..lots of love from Pennsylvania Dutch.
cosmicforums 1 year ago
Agreed..just enjoy the music! what is it with you people? If you don't like it, switch off!
patrickjs865 1 year ago
NSDAP SONG LOL
BRRUUUAAHHable 1 year ago
German ppl are very nice :)) I love your culture!! i don't care what was in the past, I don't care who killed whom!! Yes, these wars were very big mistakes, yes, the Germans killed my great grandfather-that's true! BUT it was in past!! Everything has changed. I know that Germans realize everything and they're not thinking about bad days of past years... The Germans are great people! YES, YOU SHOULD BE PROUD OF YOUR COUNTRY!!! LOTS OF LOVE FROM GEORGIA!! LOVE& P E A C E !!!!
xTATUSSYx 1 year ago 2
Nochmal!
orguggemada 1 year ago
@momogoesrawwwr too bad, but there's lots of people in America that respects and even admires Germans for their culture and music, take me for example ;)
Patriot4300212016 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 Das ist nich normal, those americans always judge people while in there own country after world war two and before there's more racism then in the rest of the world, they never expirienced a war on there own soil after the civil war.
pyromaniaknl 1 year ago
@pyromaniaknl da stimme ich voll und ganz zu,mein freund
udo701 1 year ago
I am American and am very proud of my German heritage. (So please refer to these idiots only as Stupid people and leave the nationality out of it.) Germany is rich in culture and beauty. Most everyone I have met there has been warm, accommodating, and genuine.
ExCop125 1 year ago 2
Anyone who visits there will enjoy it very much. If not, it is their own fault. This is a sweet song performed by children and political discussions have no place here. Let's enjoy our differences and this song. Viel Spaß!
ExCop125 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 In America people connect "German" with "NAZI" even though the war ended more than 60 yrs ago. just ignore the fuckers because clearly they are plain ignorant.
Patriot4300212016 1 year ago
@Patriot4300212016
Your folks should stop insulting my country. How many Germans have you seen, mocking 9/11? I haven't seen any.
But i see Americans gloating over the 600 000 German women & children they killed in Roosevelt's wicked Firestorm-Holocausts in German cities. Remember, the Germans never attacked any city in the USA and never killed any American child or woman. The USA had no right to wipe our cities off the map and to kill over half a million of our mothers & children.
Elberiver11 1 year ago 2
@Patriot4300212016
And its even more strange that Americans insult us even today, now that the war is history, as you said yourself. Also very strange: America killed far more innocents in the Red-Indian Holocaust than Hitler killed Jews. And yet America has thousand Holocaust memorials with the aim to insult Germany - but they dont have a memorial for their own holocaust. I think this is most peculiar.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
Americans do no seem to know that Hitler was only possible because America and Britain prepared the ground for Fascism at Versailles 1919. Millions of Germans were occupied by hostile Aliens and Enemy forces. Hitler drove them out, which is the reason for his success. If the Americans and Britons had not enslaved Germany under Tyranny of Aliens, Hitler would not have happened.
Most Americans do not seem to know, that America started WW II with Germany - not the other way round.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 Its true that we set the ground work for Hitler. Its also true that we did in our own way have a holocaust, and maybe we are thumbing our noses at you by puting up holocaust memorials. But dont EVER blame us for doing what we had to do to win a war. I dont remember you being to gentle with Paris, or London, or Stalingrad. Now, lets enjoy the music and ignore our friends who insist on fighting.
zegermandude 1 year ago
@zegermandude "Not gentle" with Paris or London? LOL Paris is undestroyed, bnecause a "bad nazi saved it. London started bombing Germany - Gemany bombed London back. Go buy a history book, fool.
And you being from America should not talk about cities not being handled" gently" - your satanist worshipping president Roosevfelt wiped whole cities off the map. Ever heard of Hamburg? A city the area size of London. But london had a few broken houses, but half of Hamburg was WIPED OUT.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
@zegermandude you murdered over 40 000 children and women in only three nights - you called the mass execution of civilians "Operation Gomorrha". Compare that to the few 380 civilians in Coventry. And note that the Germans wer decent people, not crooks like you British bastards, because they targeted Coventry which was centre of the BRITISH WAR INDUSTRY. But the Americns and British targeted HOSPITAL CITIES like DRESDEN. Dresden was a HOLOCAUOST, dude, so shut up.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
Germans have caused the jews so much pain, they starved them too death, and even gassed them, after that they cremated the bodies. They killed about 6 millions Jews. He tried to kill the russians to own their land as well. Fuck Hitler, I hope he burns in hell for all the pain he has caused.
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Generatorsarefake yeah....i don't want to negote that, but what the fuck, this is 60 years PASSED now....i didn't do it! don't blame whole generations for something that happened in the past...
douches -.-
Mo0onwalker 1 year ago
@Mo0onwalker It was Hitler who did it no one said it was you, by Germans I meant Nazis. Certain events that have happened in the past can always be remembered. I'm not saying Germans are bad, all I'm saying is about what happened. I don't care if it was 60 years ago, my point is that it HAPPENED and never will be forgotten. One more thing, don't insult people by calling them bs for example "douche".
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Generatorsarefake i won't say it didn't happen....i am very sorry for what happened in those years, but at one point i have to say: this wasn't me...no one blames at a "30 seconds to mars" video 'americans' for vietnam war...for gods sake, this is about the black forest, this song was written before world war II....so what is the problem here? if you want to discuss about hitler, go to a forum, but don't shout "german nazis" at a youtube video about black forest...
Mo0onwalker 1 year ago
@Generatorsarefake and by douches i menat those people who do exactly this
Mo0onwalker 1 year ago
@Generatorsarefake Another moron who tries to insult the Germans......who are you to insult them? An American racist?
You want to REMEMBER WHAT HAPPENED? Then remember how your Kukluxklan-grandfather murdered Black people and how he exterminated 58 Million RED INDIANS of North America. .Thats what HAPPENED...
But what does your crimes in America have to do with a GERMAN Song, sung by German children, you racist idiot? Nothing. So, fuck off and spread your hate somewhere else. Racist.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 American racist? No, I was talking about the past events of what happened. I did not insult the Germans of today I insulted the Nazi's. You also have no right to call America a "global massmurder". It was in the PAST which I was talking about. There are still Germans who are racist and Americans as well. So, fuck off and spread YOUR ignorance elsewhere.
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 You shouldn't be calling other people racist, when your the racist one insulting people over the Internet as seen on your channel comments. I saw two comments that said awful things on your channel. You should learn from what you replied to me. I forgot to mention earlier, that your racist land wanted to make only one race GERMAN, they wanted to exterminate any race that wasn't German. So as I said earlier you have no right to call America a "global massmurder".
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Elberiver11 If they weren't stopped they would of continued with their desire to make one race. Even you know it, I'm not saying America is the best race in the world I was just talking about what happened, yes you are right about the murder of what happened in America, but by what you are saying you think its a land of death, do I have to remind you that nazis killed about 6 million jewish people and were going to continue.
Generatorsarefake 1 year ago
@Mo0onwalker Ich würde mit diesen Leuten gar nicht gross diskutieren. Schon gar nicht mit diesem Britisch-Amerikanischen Gesindel, die haben doch die Indianer ausgerottet. Sie ermordeten millionen.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Generatorsarefake JEWS? hahaha, what a moron you are. What about the 3.0 Million Germans you starved to death, you American racists?
Remember you started war on Germany before they declared war back on you, and remember you exterminated the Native Americans - first Holocaust in history.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
America is built on theft, blood and murder: America EXTERMINATED THE INDIANS.
America is a global massmurderer, America had racist segregation until the 1960ies, Black people had to go to University under POLICE PROTECTION, because otherwise the white American MOB would haev murdered them. THATS AMERICA - Racism, massmurder and hidden Holocausts.
Elberiver11 1 year ago
sehr begeistert...
JoergWolfgang 2 years ago
oh mein gott...
diwonja 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
can i be your nazi you swine if i cant then i will screamand cry
flakbac 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hep hep judensau
ReinholdElstner 2 years ago
Warum singen die schief? Das ist sehr schade.
snufkin789 2 years ago
Reply part #5 To anujxs1: lyrics--cont.
im Tal und auf der Höh
in the valley or on the heights)
Da liegt mir der Abschied, der Abschied im Sinn
(the farewell, the farewell remains in my mind—
der Abschied vom Schwarzwälder Tal.
the farewell from the Black Forrest valley.)
Text und Musik: Paul Schulz (1876-1924)
TRY TO GET THE VERSION BY HEINO.
WmJPa 2 years ago
WmJPa 2 years ago
Reply part #1 To anujxs1: Here are the lyrics but I must split them into several replies due to space limits here:
Es steht eine Mühle im Schwarzwälder Tal
(There stands a mill in the Black Forrest Valley) Es steht eine Mühle im Schwarzwälder Tal
(There stands a mill in the Black Forrest valley;
die klappert so leis vor sich hin
it clatters away quietly)
und wo ich geh und steh
(and wherever I go or stand
(continued...)
WmJPa 2 years ago
With loves from Turkey. My country have always believed the Germany could win 1. and 2. world wars. We shared the same faith in the 1. world war. But the allies was too crowded. Even a lion can not fight against a group of jackals. You guys even did very bravely. My congratulations..
molodoychelovek 2 years ago
continued: Because we don't need you and never will. Look at your own short and miserable history and look at what you did to the Red Indians!! I rest my case!
And the British shouldn't be so smug either, you committed your fair share of attrocities and murders in your empire's colonies, so, like the Americans, leave us Germans the hell alone. (This obviously only goes out to stupid and narrow-minded Americans and British, as 90% of you are amazing and I love being in England)
englandcalling22 2 years ago
I'm a German living in England and I have to say it's making me sick not being able to watch a single German video on here without some idiot discussing the Third Reich! 1933-1945, that's 12 years!! 12 bad years in the history of Germany, which has 50 times more history and culture than any of you American dickheads could ever imagine. Gosh, it must be so sad and depressing to live in a country like America, without culture and history. So stay the fuck there and leave us Germans the hell alone!
englandcalling22 2 years ago
You Anglo-American idiots should better start dealing with your own Holocausts and warcriminals, you have plenty of them, lots of work to do for you! So leave us alone with your Hitler/Holocaust shit! And deal with your own crimes! Idiots. How disgusting, you can't even go to a simple FOLK SONG, without being molested by these sick anglo-americans and their HITLER discussions! This fucking SUCKS.
Elberiver11 2 years ago
Comment removed
anujxs1 2 years ago
can you give me the lyrics and meaning in english??
anujxs1 2 years ago
WmJPa 2 years ago
Reply part #3 To anujxs1: lyrics--cont:
da wohnet ein Mädel so schön
there lives a girl so beautiful.)
und wo ich geh' und steh
(and wherever I go or stand
im Tal und auf der Höh
in the valley or on the heights)
Da liegt mir das Mädel, das Mädel im Sinn
the girl, the girl remains in my mind—
(cont...)
WmJPa 2 years ago
Schönes Lied, schön vorgetragen;)
Kamillo0181 2 years ago
Die Kelly Family sind musikalischer als die da oh mein gott null talent, da schlaf ich bald ein.
technfreak1 2 years ago
@technfreak1 ist ja auch nur eine schulaufführung^^
Garother 4 months ago
English subtitles please
Bonnie79 2 years ago 2
Langweiliger geht's wirklich nicht mehr! - Kartenspiel während des Singens ? - Wo gibt es so etwas? - Wer ein Lied vorträgt, sollte es - mit Text und guter Stimme - überzeugend rüber bringen! - Oder man lässt es sein, bei YouTube zu veröffentlichen, bevor man sich gänzlich blamiert!
tritonusgesang 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ohh gott ich schäm mich so wir detschen haben einfach kein rythmus im blut ey
mariemassacre2 2 years ago
Well done!! I miss some of these old songs...
opajohann 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ohh gott ich schäm mich so wir detschen haben einfach kein rythmus im blut ey
smokingjuggeler 3 years ago
a jew in the background! Gein jeuden !
morgorth3242 3 years ago
Well first:
Hitler is dead.
Second:
Why do you know it's a jew ? YES not all germans have blond hair !
TheApfelkern 2 years ago
Cus it looks like an orthodox jew do i care if Adolf Hitler is dead? national Socialistme Still lives on!
morgorth3242 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think this song is about a godam jew trying to buy some young girls while the men are off to war.she won't sell , they won't go , but he does not shut his fukin' jewish piehole!
It's either that or he's trying to sell some baby kittens...
jws54 3 years ago
Ja, niedlich! 5*
ArtNatureMusic 3 years ago 2
hihi, niedlich ...5 sterne
towelie86 3 years ago 2